Abstract
Adolescent girls are at high risk of acquiring sexually transmitted infections (STIs), including the human immunodeficiency virus (HIV). Global evidence indicates significance of comprehensive sexual education in empowering adolescents with accurate knowledge regarding safe sexual practices. Adolescents living in rural areas, particularly have inadequately developed life skills; limited health promotion knowledge and are at risk of being coerced into sexual relationships. The study aimed to assess the effect of peer group participation on improving knowledge about condoms among adolescent girls in rural eastern Ethiopia. The study analyzed data from a repeated cross-sectional study involving 3186 and 3290 adolescent girls during the baseline period (2016) and the endline period (2019), respectively. The respondents were adolescent girls aged 13–17 years old. The study’s outcome was knowledge about condoms, which was assessed using 3-item questions. A weighted multivariable logistic regression analysis was used to examine the effect of peer group participation on improving knowledge about condoms by controlling for potential confounders. Statistical significance was set at a p-value <0.05. The magnitude of good knowledge about condoms among peer-group participants was 23% higher in the endline compared to the baseline. The odds of having good knowledge about condoms among girls who participated in an organized peer group were 2.15 times higher than those who didn’t participate (AOR: 2.15, 95% CI: 1.42, 3.26). Moreover, the odds of having good knowledge about condoms among those who reported high confidence in perceived communication skills were 1.68 times higher than those who reported no or little confidence (AOR: 1.68, 95% CI: 1.33, 2.13). Peer-group participation improved knowledge about condoms. Girls with high confidence in their perceived communication skills also had better knowledge about condoms. Peer-group education interventions have the potential to improve condom knowledge and thus improve sexual and reproductive health outcomes of adolescent girls. Further studies are needed in other contexts to inform intervention scale-up.
Introduction
Adolescence brings changes, including health challenges linked to the onset of sexual activity. Evidence related to adolescents’ physical health primarily focuses on adolescents over 15 years, while younger adolescents get little attention as they are considered too young (1). In sub-Saharan Africa, more girls than boys are sexually active at a younger age, within or outside the confines of marriage, with a corresponding increase in the risk of sexually transmitted infections (STIs), including Human Immunodeficiency Virus (HIV) (2–5). Condom use remains relatively low among adolescents despite extensive efforts (6).
Adolescent girls’ sexual and reproductive health (SRH) needs often go unmet due to lack of crucial health knowledge necessary for informed decision-making (7,8). Knowledge about condoms plays a critical role in promoting healthy sexual behavior by addressing misconceptions and misinformation that contribute to risky sexual behaviors (9).
Curriculum-based, theory-driven, group-based interventions targeting adolescent girls’ Knowledge and skills can influence their sexual behaviors (10–12). These interventions, grounded in behavioral frameworks are delivered through interactive group sessions enabling a structured and systematic delivery of information. Interventions addressing adolescents’ sexual and reproductive health outcomes involve individual, social, and environmental level interventions (13). Individual-level interventions primarily focus on knowledge and attitude to alter girls’ risk profiles (14,15). Peer group education, as part of multi-component interventions, yields mixed results (16–18), promoting a critical decision regarding the timing of these intervention.
Timing interventions during early adolescence or mid-late adolescence is crucial in devising appropriate strategies (19), with studies suggesting the effectiveness of early intervention (20). Sensitization on SRH issues peer education sessions have proven effective in preventing HIV and STIs (21,22).
Accurate Knowledge about condoms and HIV predicts preventive sexual behaviors (23). Conversely, misconceptions about condom use, including condom ineffectiveness, inaccessibility, and re-usability increase risks for pregnancy, STIs and other poor reproductive health outcomes (24).
Research on peer group interventions among very young adolescents in sub-Saharan Africa(25–27) is limited, reflecting the overall lack of attention to interventions in this demographic (28). Understanding the impact of interventions targeting adolescents is critical for meeting sustainable development goals(SDGs), Goal 3 on universal access to SRH services, including family planning, information and education to promote contraceptive use and prevent adolescent births (29); and African Union’s Agenda 2063, that seeks to address adolescent SRH needs (Somefun et al., 2021).
This study intends to uncover the factors that facilitate the acquisition of condom-related knowledge, providing vital insights for crafting targeted interventions aimed at improving sexual SRH outcomes among adolescent girls. With a burgeoning population of at-risk adolescents, it’s imperative to identify practical, adaptable, and cost-effective interventions catering to the SRH needs of adolescent girls, particularly in resource-constrained setting like Ethiopia. Inconsistent and non-continuous condom use persist in SSA countries, including Ethiopia. Thus, addressing knowledge-related issues stands as a crucial step in tackling sexual health risks, including unsafe sexual practices, a pressing public health concern for adolescents(31).
Therefore, this study aimed to examine the effect of peer-group participation on the improvement of knowledge about condoms among adolescent girls.
Materials and Methods
Study description
The study used data obtained from a quasi-experimental study called ‘Abdiboru’ project conducted as an implementation research project that assessed interventions to address structural issues facing adolescent girls in Western Hararghe zone, Oromia region, Eastern Ethiopia. The baseline survey was conducted from 31/05/2016 to 11/08/2016 and the endline survey was conducted from 09/10/2019 to 23/11/2019. The study population were adolescent girls aged 13-17 years old at the time of the surveys (Fig 1). Adolescent girls were sampled using a multi-stage sampling method, at first using simple random sampling method of clusters, followed by selection of households using computer generated random number that were identified after conducting complete census of the study area(32). For this study, 3186 and 3290 adolescent girls’ data were made available, from the baseline and endline surveys, respectively. The response rate for the baseline and endline surveys were 93.15% and 96.19%, respectively. Data for both surveys were collected using a structured and pretested interviewer-administered questionnaire that was translated into the local language, Affaan Oromo, for field use.
About the peer-group participation intervention covered in the study
The peer groups were formed by 25-30 adolescent girls aged 10-14 years old who then went on to receive intervention for a three-year period (Figure 1). Each group upon formation, elected two representatives to facilitate their meetings. These two representatives participated in the training of trainers (TOTs) on the sexual and reproductive health (SRH) intervention curriculum prepared by the implementer, so they can go back to their groups and facilitate the discussions. Most peer groups meet every week, but some groups might also meet once every 2 weeks or once a month. Groups would meet in a permanent location, either in the school compound or in the village as per the groups’ consensus. The sexual and reproductive health intervention curriculum that was prepared and implemented had 11 discussion topics including, topics on Female Reproductive organ, Male reproductive organ, Puberty, Menstruation hygiene management, Pregnancy, Early marriage, Gender based violence, Family planning, STI (mode of transmission + prevention and treatment + HIV), Friendly health services, and the basic needs of adolescents. The groups would discuss each topic in each meeting session. Sessions were organized following the principles of participatory dialogue. They introduced materials and used participatory approaches such as role play, open-ended stories, and picture games to encourage dialogue on an equal footing within the group(33,34). The peer-group intervention was implemented in three districts, which served as the intervention arm. Another district that didn’t receive the implementation served as the control arm. After a three-year implementation period, the intervention population would grow to be 13-17 years old and serve as the study population for the endline survey.
Measurement
Outcome variable
The outcome variable was Knowledge about condoms, assessed based on three questions. The three questions had “Yes”, “No” and “don’t know” response options. Adolescent girls who said “Yes” to questions “Condom can be used to prevent pregnancy” and “Condom can protect against getting HIV/AIDS and other sexually transmitted diseases; and also said “No” to the question “a condom can be reused” were considered to have good Knowledge about Condom.
Predictor variable
For exposure to peer-group participation intervention, an adolescent who lived in the intervention arm was considered as part of a peer group. Girls in the control arm were not considered part of the peer-group.
For peer group participation-Survey time interaction term, peer group participation(P1) was labeled as “1” and not participating(P0) was labeled as “0”. With regards to survey time, baseline(T0) was labelled as “0” and endline(T1) was labeled as “1”. The interaction term was constructed by combining these variables; hence adolescents who lived in the intervention arm and were assessed during the endline time(P1T1) were labeled as “1(Yes)”, Girls who lived in the control arm and were assessed during the baseline time(P0T0) and endline time (P0T1), and intervention arm participants assessed during the baseline (P1T0) were labeled as “0(No)”.
Covariates
Perceived communication skill level was assessed using a single-item question about their perceived level of confidence and adolescent girls responded as “no/little confidence”, “moderate confidence” and “high confidence”(35).
Health Extension workers(HEW) are community health workers who are tasked with providing basic curative, promotive and preventive services by conducting home and school visits(36). Reported ever having had contact with HEW was considered as one of the covariates.
Data analysis
Data were analyzed using STATA/SE 14.0. Descriptive analysis was conducted to assess the magnitude of knowledge about condoms as per adolescent girl’s peer group participation and socio-demographic and other behavioral characteristics. Multivariable regression analysis controlled for covariates such as Adolescent girls’ age, education, marital status and contact with health extension workers. Intervention, survey time, intervention-survey time interaction term was also included in the analysis to estimate the effect of the intervention on the outcome. Intervention effect was examined using Odds ratio with 95% confidence intervals, and statistical significance was declared at p<0.05. Appropriate weighting was done to account for the complex survey design and analysis.
Ethics approval
The original study protocol was approved by the Institutional Review Board of Addis Continental Institute of Public Health (Ref No. ACIPH/IRB/005/2016). Informed verbal consent was obtained from all study participants in the presence of parents/guardians. For participants below the age of 15 years, additional parental/guardian-informed verbal consent was obtained. All interviews took place in a private setting to assure confidentiality. Permission for data use was sought and secured from the main study principal investigator. No personal identifiers were linked with the dataset that was made available and utilized for this study.
Results
Most respondents in both surveys attended primary school (49.2% and 54.7%) and were not married (88.01% and 93.25%). (Table 1)
Nearly eight out of ten (76.83%) adolescents reported moderate to high confidence in their communication during the baseline, while almost nine out of ten girls reported the same in the endline. In both surveys, only one out of ten girls reported ever having contact with health extension workers (Community health workers) (Table 2).
In terms of intervention status, the magnitude of good Knowledge among peer-group participants during endline was 23 percent higher compared to the baseline, while among the non-peer-group, there was a decrease. (Table 3)
The weighted multivariable logistic regression analysis showed that the odds of having good Knowledge about condoms among girls who had peer-group participation assessed during the endline time was 2.15 times higher than those who didn’t participate and were assessed during the baseline time (Adjusted OR: 2.156, 95% CI: 1.425, 3.26). Moreover, the odds of having good Knowledge about condoms among those who reported high confidence in perceived communication skills were 1.68 times higher than those who reported no/little confidence (Adjusted OR: 1.682, 95% 1.329, 2.129). (Table 4)
Discussion
The objective of this study was to assess how peer-group involvement impacts the enhancement of condom-related knowledge among adolescent girls. Peer-group participation significantly improved knowledge level on condoms among adolescents. Knowledge about condoms was also higher among girls who reported moderate to high confidence in their communication skill. Adolescent girls who had peer-group education had better Knowledge about condoms. This finding aligns with established literature demonstrating the effectiveness of peer-based education in improving HIV risk reduction knowledge, particularly regarding condom use (37). Studies conducted in India(38,39), Nigeria(26), and Ghana (40) further corroborate this result. Notably, systematic reviews from Western Pacific region also highlight the significant enhancement of adolescents’ knowledge through peer education (41).
Peer-group interventions offer a conductive platform for discussing sensitive issues, facilitating more comfortable communication among adolescent girls compared to adult-led interventions(16). Researches underscore the effectiveness of intervening during early adolescence in low and middle-income countries, highlighting the improvement in health mediators and health behaviors(42,43). Such forums enable knowledge sharing among adolescent girls, which has been effective in sub-Saharan countries, especially within school-based peer-group interventions (23,27,44,45). Moreover, establishing Girls’ clubs locally can serve as an entry point for the implementing impactful interventions without being resource intensive. Initial work is important in training students, to lead discussions within these clubs, coupled with teachers’ oversight and support, presents a feasible and sustainable approach.
However, the plight of out-of-school adolescent girls remains overlooked, with limited evidence of community-based interventions addressing their needs (17,26). Lack of access to comprehensive sexual education, limited access to health services and economic vulnerabilities are risks that make these girls more vulnerable. Addressing adolescent girls in these low-resource settings necessitates resource allocation in identifying, organizing, training, and monitoring activities, typically by diverse bodies such as NGOs community, or local organizations. Furthermore, creating cost-effective and sustainable interventions becomes pivotal in such contexts, often requiring community centers as meeting points for adolescent girls.
Furthermore, the study emphasizes the importance of communication skills in influencing adolescent girls’ knowledge about condoms. Studies from South Africa and Colombia underscored the pivotal role of good communication skills in fostering protective behavior(23) and addressing gaps in sexual health knowledge(46).
Notably, the study’s strength lies in its employment of a significant sample size, ensuring robustness in evaluating intervention impacts. Additionally, the research delved into early intervention effects on adolescent sexual health knowledge, an area often overlooked. However, the study’s limitation is its inability to assess condom use timing and correct application, components of knowledge that could have enriched the depth of knowledge assessment and produced a comprehensive evaluation of knowledge depth.
Conclusion
In conclusion, peer-group participation improved adolescent girls’ knowledge about condoms. In addition, condom-related knowledge was associated with good perceived communication skills. Peer-group education interventions have the potential to improve condom knowledge and thus improve sexual and reproductive health outcomes of adolescent girls. Further studies are needed to evaluate the effectiveness of the intervention in other contexts to inform intervention scale-up and adoption into national adolescent health promotion strategies.
Data Availability
All data relevant to the study are included in the manuscript. The data can also be accessible upon request.
Acknowledgements
The authors would like to acknowledge the Abdiboru project for providing the data for this paper.
References
