Real-world study of intranasal ketamine for use in patients with refractory chronic migraine

INTRODUCTION

Refractory chronic migraine (rCM), defined by an inadequate response to multiple proven preventive and acute medications with a significant impact on disability and quality of life (QOL),¹ is highly pervasive in tertiary headache clinics. Ketamine, a dissociative anesthetic agent, has potential utility for perioperative pain, chronic pain, depression, and headache,^2,3 especially when used with benzodiazepines to mitigate psychomimetic AEs.⁴ Known as a non-competitive N-Methyl-D-aspartate (NMDA) receptor antagonist, ketamine inhibits nitric oxide synthase, proinflammatory cytokine release, and serotonin reuptake. It antagonizes voltage-gated sodium channels, large-conductance potassium channels, L-type voltage-dependent calcium channels, calcitonin gene-related peptide (CGRP) receptors, and nicotinic acetylcholine receptors. Ketamine also activates μ/δ opioid receptors, AMPA receptors, and GABA_A receptors, and upregulates brain-derived neurotrophic factor.^3,5-7 There are two stereoisomers: S(+) and R(-), where S(+) isomer is 3- to 4-fold more potent than R(-) but has quicker clearance. The mechanism of action for ketamine in antinociception is likely multifactorial beyond NMDA but remains unclear.⁸

To date, several randomized control trials (RCTs) have been published on subanesthetic ketamine infusion for headache management.⁹ Since 2000, Thomas Jefferson University Hospital has been using subanesthetic ketamine infusions for multiple chronic pain conditions, including chronic regional pain syndrome and headache. We published several retrospective cohort studies demonstrating ketamine infusion’s potential utility in managing rCM.^10-13

However, intravenous (IV) ketamine typically requires dose titration and AE monitoring by a pain specialist in the hospital, thus limiting its use in the outpatient setting. IN ketamine, with its simple storage and convenient administration, is an attractive alternative to IV administration. It has rapid systemic absorption (time of onset 5-10 minutes) without first-pass hepatic metabolism but with 25-50% bioavailability (higher than oral ketamine). The FDA has recently approved esketamine (Spravato; Janssen, Raritan, NJ), an IN S (+) enantiomer for treatment-resistant depression; its use in treating headache or migraine has not been studied.

Over the last few years, IN ketamine has been evaluated for acute pain management.^14,15 While there is some evidence behind IN ketamine as a treatment for headache disorders (e.g., migraine, cluster headache, non-traumatic headache) in several studies,^16-21 its role in treating rCM has not been well described nor validated. At our center, IN ketamine is often prescribed to patients with rCM who do not respond well to standard infusion treatments, including dihydroergotamine and lidocaine, before or after a scheduled ketamine infusion. We hypothesized that IN ketamine alleviates acute headaches in patients with rCM as adjunctive therapy to their standard-of-care headache management. To better understand the real-world benefit of IN ketamine, we retrospectively reviewed the effectiveness and tolerability of IN ketamine in patients with rCM as outpatients at a tertiary headache center.

METHODS

This single-center study was approved by the Thomas Jefferson University Institutional Review Board (#20E.147). It involves retrospective chart reviews and phone interviews with established patients at the Jefferson Headache Center (JHC). Patients who did not have success with multiple standard migraine treatments were offered IN ketamine scripts (100mg/ml, 30ml), which were formulated by a local compounding pharmacy to approximately 10mg per 0.1ml spray and instructed to use 1-3 sprays each nostril per dose at the discretion of their JHC providers. IN ketamine safety precautions were reviewed with patients to decrease the risk of addiction and misuse. All patients given IN ketamine scripts were required to sign a treatment contract agreeing to frequent follow-up visits, avoid use before driving, refrain from using other controlled substances without our knowledge or alcohol, and avoid pregnancy.

We identified patients who received IN ketamine scripts between 1/1/2019 to 2/29/2020 through an electronic medical record query. Eligible patients were at least 18 years of age at screening and received at least one electronic script for IN ketamine during the study period. All identified subjects were mailed a recruitment letter regarding the study, its goals, and the option to opt-out. After a 60-day waiting period, identified patients were contacted by phone to conduct a structured interview upon obtaining verbal consent. Participants were excluded if they never filled the ketamine script, received IN ketamine for non-migraine diagnoses, or could not participate via phone interview.

Two independent investigators performed chart reviews involving demographic information, headache diagnoses, comorbidities, headache characteristics, current and past preventive regimens, medication overuse at the time of review, and the setting and reason for IN ketamine initiation. Through phone interviews, we collected data including current IN ketamine regimen (dose, frequency), time to pain relief, consistency of pain relief, changes in pain level (11-point numerical rating scale) before and after use, global impression of effectiveness, the overall impact on QOL, pain catastrophizing scale, and self-efficacy scale and AEs. The collected information was stored on a HIPAA-compliant web-based REDCap electronic data capture tool hosted at Thomas Jefferson University.²² Upon data cleaning and verification, the senior investigator determined final data approval.

RESULTS

In total, 242 rCM patients were prescribed IN ketamine, and 169 were successfully contacted, consented, and interviewed. The remaining 55 patients could not be reached, and 18 declined participation. Table 1 illustrates the demographics of the study population. While all patients had a migraine diagnosis (with 38.5% having aura), coexisting headache diagnoses included new-daily persistent headache (n=22, 13.0%), post-traumatic headache (n=8, 17.8%), and idiopathic intracranial hypertension (n=5, 3.0%). Common comorbidities included psychiatric disorders (e.g., anxiety, depression, bipolar, PTSD) and other somatic symptoms (e.g., back, neck, TMJ pain). The participants were mostly Caucasian (161, 95.3%), female (79.9%), 44.3±13.8 years old, with a BMI of 30.36±7.78, and college/graduate education (56.2%). They reported 25.0±8.7 monthly headache days (MHD) and 13.7±10.2 monthly disabling headache days, where more than two-thirds (67.5%) had daily headaches. Forty-four patients (45.6%) were on employment disability. On average, they tried 6.9±3.1 preventive medications in the past and were on 2.6±1.7 preventive medications at the time of the interview. 143 (84.6%) and 38 (22.5%) tried more than 3 or 5 classes of preventive medications. While 101 (59.8%) and 86 (50.9%) previously tried CGRP mAbs and onabolulinumtoxinA, 89 (52.7%) and 73 (43.2%) were on these treatments, respectively, at the time of the interview. For acute treatment, the most prescribed medications were ketorolac injection (51, 30.2%), and dihydroergotamine injection (41, 24.3%). The pain catastrophizing scale and self-efficacy scale were 4.73±3.33 and 7.96±2.28, respectively, at the time of the interview.

One hundred ten patients (65.1%) were current IN ketamine users. Forty-one (24.7%) and forty-six (27.7%) patients were offered IN ketamine before and after ketamine infusion, respectively. 47.6% had never received ketamine infusion. The most common reasons for initiating IN ketamine were an incomplete response to prior acute medications (100, 59.2%), incomplete response to prior preventives (52, 30.8%), prior benefit from IV ketamine (38, 22.5%), and unsuccessful lidocaine infusion (22, 13.0%). Concomitant acute medications included NSAIDs (n=85, 50.3%), DHE (n=52, 30.8%), triptans (n=34, 20.1%), neuroleptics (n=60, 35.5%), opioids (n=21, 12.4%), gepants (n=35, 20.7%), simple analgesics (n=22, 13.0%), and cannabinoids (n=20, 11.8%). Table 2 shows the effectiveness metrics of IN ketamine. Overall, patients used roughly 7.8 sprays per day and 12 days per month. Twenty-three (13.6%) were daily users, and 31 (18.3%) used more than 10 sprays per day. Nine used it as preventive, and 11 for the aura. There was a decrease of 2.87±1.95 (within group p<0.001) in pain intensity after using IN ketamine. The average time for onset of pain relief was 73.63 minutes, with 70.6% treatment response consistency. Compared to other acute medications, IN ketamine was reported as much better in 43.2% (n=73), somewhat better in 29.6% (n=50), and no different or worse in 22.6% (n=38). One hundred twenty patients (71.0%) reported using fewer acute medications. When evaluating overall effectiveness, 83 (49.1%) found it very effective, 67 (39.6%) somewhat effective, 16 (9.5%) reported no change, and 3 (1.8%) reported worse than prior acute medications. Within the same group, 60 (35.5%) found the overall impact of IN ketamine on their QOL to be much better, 72 (42.6%) found it to be somewhat better, 31 (18.3%) reported no change, and 6 (3.6%) worse.

We evaluated pain intensity change and overall impression (very effective vs. others) using GLM adjusted for age, sex, and BMI. Demographics (e.g., age, sex, BMI) were not significantly associated with pain intensity change or very effective response. The very effective overall impression and pain intensity change were found to be significantly associated with the current use of IN ketamine (odds ratio of 5.601 [2.436-10.5] and 1.908 [1.029-3.539]) but not others (Table 3).

Table 4 lists the AEs reported by the participants. One hundred twenty-five patients (74.0%) reported at least one AE. Fatigue and double vision/blurred vision were the most common, followed by cognitive AEs (e.g., confusion/dissociation, vivid dreams, hallucination). Reported nausea and dizziness were expected, as known AEs from ketamine. In addition, among 142 participants with laboratory data, alanine and aspartate transaminase elevations (>3x upper normal limit) were found in 4.9% (n=7) and 2.1% (n=3), respectively, without bilirubin elevation. Short-term transaminase elevations were discovered during inpatient ketamine infusion (n=4), while others were due to medical issues (e.g., fatty liver, gallstones). KNS usage continued afterward without complication.

DISCUSSION

In this retrospective single-center study with 169 interviewed participants, mostly with rCM who were unsuccessful with multiple preventive medications and biologics, adjunctive IN ketamine significantly improved acute headache pain intensity with consistent treatment response and reductions in other acute medication use. This is the first outpatient IN ketamine study for rCM. Almost half of the participants considered IN ketamine very effective, and more than two-thirds of patients found it improved their QOL, especially among current active users. Variables such as daily headache, number of IN ketamine spray/day and day/month, previous response to ketamine infusion, pain catastrophizing score, and self-efficacy score were not associated with pain intensity change or overall effectiveness. Although almost three-quarters reported having at least one AE, particularly fatigue, vision disturbances, and cognitive issues, many continued using it.

To date, there are only a limited number of studies using IN ketamine for headache treatment (Table 5). In 2000, Kaube et al. presented a case series of 11 patients with familial hemiplegic migraine who self-administered 25mg of IN ketamine. Five showed reduced severity and duration of the neurological deficit.¹⁶ In 2013, Afridi et al. reported the first double-blind, randomized controlled trial (DBRCT) comparing IN ketamine 25mg against IN midazolam 2mg in 18 patients with migraine with prolonged aura. IN ketamine reduced the severity (p=0.032) but not the duration of the aura, whereas midazolam had no effect.¹⁷ In the THINK trial (single-blind RCT), Benish et al. compared IN ketamine (0.75 mg/kg) vs. IN ketamine (0.015 mg/kg) + IV metoclopramide (10mg) + oral diphenhydramine (25mg) in 53 patients with primary headache syndrome in the emergency department (ED). The average change in pain visual analog scale (VAS) at 30 min post-intervention (the primary endpoint) was 22.2 mm in the control arm vs. 29.0 in the IN ketamine arm (effect size difference 6.8 mm, 95% CI -5.8 to 19.4); no statistically significant difference.¹⁸ Recently, Sarvari et al., in a DBRCT investigated the efficacy of IN ketamine (0.75 mg/kg) vs. IV ketorolac (30mg) in 140 patients with non-traumatic acute headache in the ED. Pain reduction was significantly greater in IN ketamine than in IV ketorolac at 30, 60, and 120 min.²¹ These RCTs showed that IN ketamine may be as effective as the standard IV headache regimen. Apart from RCTs, Turner et al. retrospectively reviewed 34 patients with status migrainosus receiving IN ketamine (0.1-0.2 mg/kg) in an inpatient setting. Twenty-five (73.5%) were responders with an average pain score reduction of -7.2 from admission to discharge,¹⁹ suggesting potential utility in severe migraine. Petersen et al. also showed that IN ketamine 15mg every 6 minutes (max 5 uses) could reduce pain intensity of 1.1 (95%CI −0.6 to 2.7) in 15 minutes and 4.3 (95%CI 2.4-6.2) in 30 minutes among 20 cluster headache patients.²⁰ Esketamine, a S-enantiomer of ketamine, was FDA-approved for treatment-resistant depression. Considering that depression and anxiety are significant comorbidities associated with headache disorders, IN ketamine could potentially treat depression in patients with rCM. It is important to know that all studies reported AEs, including dizziness, nausea, increased BP/HR, fatigue, and mood change. While these AE were expected, they were temporary and resolved within a few hours. Based on these studies, IN ketamine appeared to reduce head pain quickly and effectively, at least for common headaches in the ED. Our study, which included mostly patients with rCM, further expands the potential utility of IN ketamine in the refractory headache population.

Since ketamine has a relatively short half-life (about 2 hrs), refractory headache patients may tend to use it more regularly despite receiving counseling. In our population, 23 (13.6%) used it daily, 37 (21.9%) at least 15 days/month, and 76 (45.0%) at least 10 days/month. Although, the usage frequency was not associated with pain intensity change or overall effectiveness. While daily headache is generally considered more refractory to treatment, there was no difference in the usage frequency between those with or without daily headache (12.03±8.44 vs. 10.75±9.90 days/month, p=0.387; 7.4±5.19 vs. 8.31±9.64 sprays/day, p=0.428). Even though almost three-quarters of the participants reported AEs, many continued to use IN ketamine and reported better responses than other abortive medications. The active metabolite of ketamine, hydroxynorketamine, has a much longer half-life than that of ketamine and lacks the addictive effect.^23,24 Hydroxynorketamine provides an additional mechanism of action; it blocks NMDA receptor currents with low affinity and weak voltage dependence, and it is effective when applied to resting receptors.²⁵ It also elicits antidepressant effects via the inhibition of AMPA glutamate and α7 nicotinic cholinergic receptors.⁵ With hydroxynorketamine’s longer half-life, the frequent use of ketamine may lead to the accumulation of hydroxynorketamine to provide better pain inhibition, as seen in the ketamine infusion study.¹² However, the optimal dosage for IN ketamine that is safe and effective remains to be determined.

To date, guidelines around the optimal dose of IN ketamine are lacking. IN ketamine has a Tmax of 10-20 minutes and a wide bioavailability of 8-45%.²⁶ However, such metrics were gathered from blood and may not reflect ketamine’s actual distribution in the trigeminal system. It is important to understand that IN absorption varies by the nasal spray apparatus, nasal passage, site of deposition, spray viscosity, and other factors. In our study, ketamine was delivered via a traditional metered-dose spray pump with 100 μL (10mg) per spray (without any mucoadhesive or permeabilization agent), generating particles between 50-100 μm in diameter. Some studies used MAD Nasal™, which is an atomization device that produces smaller particles (30-100 μm) and delivers deeper/higher into the nasal cavity and less to the lung than the typical nasal spray.^27,28 Compared to the lower nasal space, its upper counterpart allows for more efficient absorption due to looser olfactory epithelium tight function, lower mucociliary clearance, and richer vascular/lymphatic system.²⁹ Lipophilic small molecules such as ketamine can be transported via transcellular, paracellular, and perineural pathways via trigeminal nerves,^29,30 offering a possible delivery route to the trigeminal ganglia bypassing the blood-ganglion barrier. It is plausible that the local concentration within the trigeminal system may be higher than the serum concentration, creating a localized antinociceptive effect with lower systemic AE. Even though our participants used an average of 78mg per day, which is much lower than the infusion daily dose (0.5-1 mg/kg/hr; 960-1920 mg daily for an 80 kg person), the cephalic analgesic effect and psychometric AEs were still apparent. At this time, without a specific biomarker reflecting ketamine’s local concentration, the optimal dosage may require individual titration to find a good balance between safety and efficacy. At Jefferson, we routinely ask patients to titrate from a lower dose and limit the IN ketamine use for their headache (not other somatic pain) to a maximum of 20 sprays a day and 40 sprays a week. Participants were instructed to cautiously try different dosages while monitoring ketamine’s potential AEs to avoid overuse or intoxication.