Abstract
BACKGROUND Farmers’ pesticide management practices are critical to restoring their health following exposure to pesticides. Pesticide safety management is poorly understood by the majority of farmers. If too many dangerous disinfectants are utilized, human health will be compromised. Therefore, this study aims to investigate the prevalence of health symptoms and their association with blood cholinesterase levels among chili farmers in Sakon Nakhon Province.
METHODS A cross-sectional analytic study of 141 chili farmers was conducted. A health volunteer/research assistant collected data using a self-report questionnaire. A six-part questionnaire was provided. All subjects provided blood samples to be tested for acetylcholinesterase (AChE) inhibition by a medical technician in the laboratory. The Faculty of Medicine at Ramathibodi Hospital analysis report using a standard test kit for acetylcholinesterase (erythrocyte). Multivariate logistic regression models were used to predict the link between blood cholinesterase levels and health symptoms among chili farmers.
RESULTS Farmers’ blood levels of the enzyme cholinesterase were at risk in 94 people (risk group) 66.7% and normal in 47 people 33.3% (normal group). A study discovered the prevalence of health symptoms and blood cholinesterase levels among chili farmers included nervous system of 53.2%, muscular system of 37.6%, respiratory system of 34.8%, skin system of 9.9% and gastrointestinal system of 1.4%. In addition, logistic regression models revealed a strong association between blood cholinesterase levels and health symptoms after adjustment. The cholinesterase levels at risk (<1.30 U/g) were at increased risk of developing health conditions in nervous system 2.2 times (AOR = 2.29; 95% CI = 1.10–4.76, p-value = 0.02), muscular system 3.5 times (AOR = 3.51; 95% CI = 1.49–8.27, p-value = 0.004), respiratory system 2.2 times (AOR = 2.28; 95% CI = 1.01–5.14, p-value = 0.04) and integumentary system 7.8 times (AOR = 7.87; 95% CI = 1.00–62.13. p-value = 0.05) of chili farmers with blood cholinesterase level normal level (≥1.30 U/g).
CONCLUSION In this study, cholinesterase levels at risk (<1.30 U/g) were at risk of developing health conditions. Therefore, advocating for improved personal protection equipment and educating farmers about pesticide impact practices may also contribute to the reduction in chemical exposure.
Introduction
Highly dangerous pesticides can have immediate or persistent harmful effects, putting young people in particular in danger. Their extensive usage has resulted in health issues and deaths in many regions globally. (World Health Organization, 2022) The most serious problem among farm workers is pesticide exposure. The majority of agricultural tasks, such as pesticide mixing and spraying, harvesting, and growing, are performed manually, exposing farm workers to hazardous chemicals in agriculture. (Kangkhetkron & Juntarawijit, 2021) Approximately 25 million people globally experience unintentional pesticide poisoning annually, resulting in 200,000 deaths. In addition, the excessive and unsafe use of pesticides represents a serious risk to human health, the environment, andthe quality of food. (Buralli et al., 2020)
Thailand’s agricultural chemical import for 2019 revealed that agricultural chemicals were imported, and the vast majority were insecticides. (Saran Wattanathada, 2019) Organophosphates (OPs) and carbamates (CA) are the most used families of pesticides. They are particularly dangerous to human health and are the primary cause of pesticide poisoning in LMICs. (Buralli et al., 2020)(Kapeleka, Sauli, Sadik, & Ndakidemi, 2019) Approximately 80.0% of the participants had detectable residues of chlorpyrifos and profenofos on their hands. In addition, half of the participants reported acute health symptoms within 48 hours after applying pesticides. Furthermore, root and root rot, powdery mildew, anthracnose, leaf spot, wilt, leaf wilt, and leaf blight have been identified as serious chili pepper diseases. (Somjit Boonpha & Pornpun Sakunkoo, 2018)
The majority of farmers are exposed to pesticides that enter the body through the skin and breathing thus affecting health symptoms. (Kapeleka et al., 2019) This is because most farmers engage in improper chemical use practices and heavily rely on pesticides such as organophosphate and carbamate to boost agricultural production. Consequently, this results in both immediate and long-term health implications, and it affects blood cholinesterase exposure to pesticides that enter the body through the skin contaminated through breathing (Ministry of Public Health, 2022). Only the initial field screening of blood cholinesterase levels was used to monitor the usage of pesticides. However, limited studies have analyzed the unusual laboratory confirmation of blood cholinesterase levels in Thailand. Therefore, this study investigates the prevalence of health symptoms and their association with occupational blood cholinesterase levels among chili farmers in Sakon Nakhon Province, Thailand.
Materials and Methods
Study design and participants
A cross-sectional analytic study investigated the association between blood cholinesterase levels and chili farmers’ health in Sakon Nakhon Province. The data were collected between September 2021 and March 2022. We utilized a special randomized sampling approach in our investigation. Purposive sampling was used, and we specifically chose chili producers in Sakon Nakhon Province. Obtained by calculating the sample size using the formula for estimating the proportion of the population in cases where the entire population is known (Enderlein, 1995). We increased the sample number by 20% to prevent sample discrepancy. A total of 141 chili farmers were located in Muang districts, Sakon Nakhon Province. In the confounders section many factors, such as congenital illness, muscle relaxants, or pain, alter the enzyme acetylcholinesterase and interfered with the interpretation of cholinesterase test findings. Remedies reduce the quantity of neurotransmitters by inhibiting the action of certain enzymes. According to study evaluations, certain compounds stimulate enzymes and others enhance the amount of neurotransmitters. Furthermore, chemical pesticides, expertise in cultivating chilies, and chemical consumption all impact health symptoms.
Due to the widespread use of chemicals in pest management and elimination, the majority of farmers utilize chemical pesticides to boost agricultural output. However, this impacts both acute and chronic health. Using the selection criteria, results in a variety of ailments and diseases (Ministry of Public Health, 2022) One chili farmer was selected in each household based on convenience. Chili farmers considered eligible were those aged over 30 years, registered for the occupation of chili farmers for over a year, capable of reading and writing, and those who agreed to participate in the project during the volunteer research. In addition, health volunteers were trained to conduct face-to-face interviews using a questionnaire. Ethical Approval was obtained from Kasetsart University, Sakon Nakhon, and the accredited human ethics committee approved the study protocol of the research (Kucsc.HE-64-022). The participants were informed of the protocol and provided written consent.
Health symptoms questionnaire
The participants in a health survey were provided a structured questionnaire. Health symptoms that occurred after using or being exposed to pesticides in the past month were divided into five symptoms as follows; 1) the nervous system symptoms including nausea, vomiting, dizziness, headache, abnormal sweating, watery eyes, palpitations, twitching eyelids, insomnia, red eyes, burning eyes, itchy eyes, numbness, drooling, blurred vision, chest pain, chest tightness, trembling hands, staggering gait, seizures, blackouts, and unconsciousness. 2) The muscular system symptoms including fatigue muscle weakness and cramping. 3) The respiratory system symptoms including dry throat, burning nose, sore throat, cough, shortness of breath, and runny nose. 4) The integumentary system symptoms including skin itching dry/chapped skin rash, blisters, and burning pain. 5) the gastrointestinal system symptoms including stomach ache and diarrhea. If the participants replied yes to at least one symptom in any system, they were judged to have symptoms in that system. We adapted the questionnaire from the Farmer’s Work Risk Assessment Form from Pesticide Exposure (NGP 1–56). (Ministry of Public Health, 2022) which were evaluated throughout the interview using self-reports designed to evaluate health issues. The reliability of the health symptoms questionnaire was piloted by 50 chili farmers in other areas which were found to be reliable with a Cronbach’s alpha coefficient of 0.75.
Measurements of blood Cholinesterase level
Blood collection for choline tester level was performed by a medical technologist. Blood was drawn with a 3 ML volume and the blood sample was taken five minutes/per person and collected at a temperature of 2°C–8°C. Toxicology laboratory method using standard acetylcholinesterase (erythrocyte) test kit. The results were analyzed by the Faculty of Medicine at Ramathibodi Hospital Bangkok. (Mulyana et al., 2020) Blood Cholinesterase levels were divided into two categories: the risk level (<1.30 U/g) and normal level (≥1.30 U/g). (Mulyana et al., 2020)
Statistical analysis
Descriptive statistics were used to evaluate and report the data as a percentage, mean, and standard deviation. The relationship between personal characteristics and health symptoms among chili farmers and the prevalence of health symptoms and blood cholinesterase levels among chili farmers were analyzed by multivariate logistic regression statistics. These were used to evaluate the relationship between blood cholinesterase levels and health symptoms among chili farmers. The potential confounding factors in the model were adjusted using the recommended factor effect for health symptoms and selected by the univariate analysis on the basis of p-value <.1, such as congenital disease, chemical pesticides, experience in planting chilies, chemical consumption, and muscle relaxants or pain remedies. A p-value of below.05 was considered statistically significant.
Results
Respondents personal characteristics
According to an analysis of the relationship between personal characteristics, there were 141 respondents, mostly females, and 52.5% of their mean age (±SD) was 51.43 (±9.49) years. Regarding marital status, 116 of were 82.3%, the majority of whom did not have any medical conditions. Not using pain relievers, smoking, or drinking alcohol. Individuals who are active in the usage of chemical pesticides The majority of them were in stay in the area where chemicals are sprayed 131 (92.9%), combine chemicals 88 (62.4%), and spraying pesticides 66 (46.8%). Farmers were the most likely to use pesticides for over five years. This resulted in health problems and they were used chemical consumption < 100 (liter/time) amount 92 (65.24%; Table 1)
Respondents’ health symptoms and blood cholinesterase levels among chili farmers
The prevalence of health symptoms and blood cholinesterase levels among chili farmers found the nervous system symptoms of 53.2% (including nausea 31.9%, dizziness 14.9%, headache, 14.2%, abnormally heavy perspiration 4.3%, tears 2.1%, heart palpitations 1.4%, and eye twitch 0.7%), the muscular system symptoms of 37.6% (including tired 37.6%), the respiratory system symptoms of 34.8% (including Feel dry 14.9%, and nasal irritation 14.2%, sore throats accounted for % of the cases, with coughing accounting for 0.7%), the skin system symptoms accounting for 9.9% (including itchy skin 8.5%, dry/cracked skin 4.3%, skin rash and blisters 0.7%) and gastrointestinal system accounting for 1.4%, including abdominal pain and diarrhea 0.7%. The results highlighted that the mean serum cholinesterase level was 1.25 ± 0.08 U/g. Furthermore, the enzyme cholinesterase in the blood among farmers were at a risk level in 94 people (66.7%) and a normal level in 47 people (33.3 %; Table 2).
The relationship between blood cholinesterase level and health symptoms among chili farmers
Table 3 shows the multivariate logistic regression models, which indicate an association between blood cholinesterase levels effects on health symptoms among chili farmers. Chili farmers with cholinesterase levels at risk (<1.30 U/g) were at risk of developing health conditions nervous system 2.1 times (OR = 2.17; 95% CI = 1.06–4.43, p-value = 0.03), the muscular system 2.6 times (OR = 2.64; 95% CI = 1.20–5.81, p-value = 0.01), the tract 2.2 times for the respiratory system (OR = 2.22; 95% CI = 1.00–4.89, p-value = 0.04), and 8.7 times for the integumentary system (OR = 8.73; 95% CI = 1.11–68.29, p-value = 0.03) of chili farmers with normal levels of cholinesterase (≥1.30U/g) at a statistically significant level of 0.05. While the gastrointestinal system was not associated with cholinesterase levels. After adjusting the model for congenital disease, chemical pesticides, experience in planting chilies, chemical consumption, and muscle relaxants or pain remedies. The odds associated with chili farmers with cholinesterase levels at risk (<1.30 U/g) were at increased risk of developing health conditions. Nervous system were 2.2 times (AOR = 2.29; 95% CI = 1.10–4.76, p-value = 0.02), muscular system was 3.5 times (AOR = 3.51; 95% CI = 1.49–8.27, p-value = 0.004), respiratory system 2.2 times (AOR = 2.28; 95% CI = 1.01–5.14, p-value = 0.04), and integumentary system 7.8 times (AOR = 7.87; 95% CI = 1.00–62.13, p-value = 0.05) for chili farmers with normal levels of cholinesterase enzyme (≥1.30U/g) at a statistically significant level of 0.05. In addition, the gastrointestinal system was not correlated with cholinesterase levels. in Table 3.
Discussion
Farmers currently continue to apply significant amounts of organophosphate pesticides to lessen insect infestations. Previous research has demonstrated that occupational exposure to carbamate and organophosphate induces acetylcholinesterase activity reduction. These results indicate a significant association between blood cholinesterase levels and health symptoms in rural community settings.
These findings highlight that chili farmers are directly related to the use of pesticides such as combined chemicals (62.4%), stay in the area where chemicals are sprayed (99.9%) and sprayer (46.8 %). Farmers use pesticides 1–7 days per month or more (91.5%). They use organophosphate (46.8%) and carbamates (16.3%; (Shentema et al., 2020)
This study divided subjects based on cholinesterase levels into two groups. Those with cholinesterase levels < 1.30 U/g, which were in the reference risk range and those with cholinesterase levels ≥ 1.30 U/g were within the normal reference range. (Mulyana et al., 2020) The results revealed that the results of screening for the enzyme cholinesterase in the blood among farmers were in risk level (66.7%) and normal level (33.3%; (Andrea Guytingco, Phayong Thepaksorn, & Richard L Neitzel, 2018; Mulyana et al., 2020) In accordance with research conducted in Indonesia and Thailand. However, this study aligns with the research of (Rosanti, Rahma, & Hamawi, 2021) which discovered that there were six farmers at very high risk, 17 farmers at high risk, 26 farmers at medium risk, and eight farmers at low risk of pesticide contamination.
After adjusting the model for congenital disease, chemical pesticides, experience in planting chilies, chemical consumption, and muscle relaxants or pain remedies. The odds associated with discovered chili farmers with cholinesterase levels at risk (<1.30 U/g) were at increased risk of developing health conditions. nervous system were 2.2 times (AOR = 2.29; 95% CI = 1.10–4.76, p-value = 0.02), and muscular system was 3.5 times (AOR = 3.51; 95% CI = 1.49–8.27, p-value = 0.004) respiratory system 2.2 times (AOR = 2.28; 95% CI = 1.01–5.14, p-value = 0.04) and Integumentary system 7.8 times (AOR = 7.87; 95% CI = 1.00–62.13, p-value = 0.05). Furthermore, it was reported that the health symptoms for neurological symptom (57.1%) followed by perspiration and headache (40.7%), poor appetite and depression (29.3%) and irritation (26.4%). conducted a study in Arusha Region. (Mwabulambo, Mrema, Ngowi, & Mamuya, 2018). It was reported for headache, dyspnea, wheezing, cough, poor digestion, tiredness, and feeling worthless, after adjustment. (Buralli et al., 2020) conducted a study in Brazil. The most common self-reported symptoms were coughing (5.7%), tiredness (5.4%), dizziness (5.1%), and dry skin and irritation (4.8%). conducted a study in the South of Thailand. (Andrea Guytingco et al., 2018) Harmful toxic pesticides enter the body through tainted skin from inhaling. Consequently, discomfort, weariness, difficulty breathing, and itching are all possible side effects. Burning on the tongue, mouth, and esophagus, as well as clouded eyesight (Rosanti et al., 2021)
This indicates an association between the effect of blood cholinesterase levels on health symptoms among chili farmers discovered nervous system, muscular system, respiratory system, and integumentary system among chili farmers. The association was obtained between blood cholinesterase levels and nausea and vomiting, dizziness, feeling parched, nasal irritation, headache, and itchy skin. This study aligns with the findings of (Kapeleka et al., 2019) who discovered that self-reported symptoms correlate to lower AChE. Prevalence of tiredness (71.6% against 15.5%) was conducted in the study in Tanzania. In addition, it was discovered that people with aberrant serum AChE levels were more likely to report dizziness as their primary symptom (12.4%) conducted a study in the South of Thailand. (Andrea Guytingco et al., 2018) Furthermore, in a study on male farmers from Buea Cameroon the employment of agrochemicals was discovered to cause a variety of symptoms, including weakness, itchiness, burning feeling, headache, sneezing, coughing, and vomiting. (Manfo, Suh, Nantia, Moundipa, & Cho-Ngwa, 2021) However, pesticide-related symptoms were the most widespread. These included dizziness, coughs, and headaches. Poor pesticide handling and application were observed, including leaking spraying tanks, smoking while working, and consuming food and alcohol in the work area. conducted a study in Thailand. (Pussadee Laor et al., 2019)
Limitations of this study and recommendations
This study had several limitations. It examined only two groups of pesticides in the body (organophosphate and carbamate), which according to data obtained from the questionnaire showed that other pesticides were also used in the cultivation of peppers. The screening of chili farmers who are at risk from using pesticides This can come for several reasons, such as inhaling pesticide droplets that spread in the air, skin exposure to chemical pesticides during chemical mixing, while spraying chemicals, or eating or drinking food that has been contaminated with pesticides. Therefore, future research should analyze the risk of pesticide exposure in non-agricultural groups. Second, determining the causal association between blood cholinesterase levels and health symptoms is difficult because a cross-sectional analytic study can only provide evidence for the possible associations of 141 participants. Finally, a small sample size was recruited for the preliminary study. However, the results indicate a significant association between blood cholinesterase levels and health symptoms in rural community settings. Consequently, further studies are required.
Regarding recommendations, budget support should be followed by help from appropriate governmental agencies on a continuous and regular basis. In addition, non-chemical pest control approaches should be adopted such as employing biological agents or other methods to urge farmers to use other materials instead of chemical pesticides. Furthermore, public health authorities should collaborate with community leaders, chili farmers, and the District Agriculture Office of Sakon Nakhon Province to organize self-defense operations. In addition, farmers who use pesticides are encouraged to obtain a blood test. Every year, farmers will be screened for cholinesterase levels in the blood to highlight the extent of poison in the body.
This study proposes that exposure to pesticide can contribute to the nervous system, muscular system, respiratory system, and integumentary system symptoms in chili farmers. Therefore, educating farmers on pesticide effects and advocating for better personal protective equipment practices can also reduce chemical exposure. This information contributes to an important foundation that will result in appropriate and effective long-term actions.
Data Availability
All data produced in the present work are contained in the manuscript All data produced are available online at
Disclosure statement
The authors declare no conflict of interest
Acknowledgments
The study was supported by Graduate Research Fellowships for publication in international academic journals, Kasetsart University. Thank you to the lecturers of the Faculty of Public Health at Kasetsart University’s Chaloem Phrakiat Campus in Sakon Nakhon Province. In addition, we thank the director of Ban Chiang Kruea Phochai Sub-District Health Promoting Hospital for your assistance and guidance during the research and all chili farmers that provided their time to gather data.