Conceptualization of Health Literacy from a Nursing Perspective

Health Literacy in Nursing Perspective

Health literacy is a process that requires knowledge, motivation, and competence to access, understand, assess, and apply health information. This process is carried out to access, understand, assess, and use health information that enables a person to improve health quality and prevent the emergence of disease (Coşkun & Bebiş, 2019). Sørensen et al. (2012) also said that decision-making in health care, disease prevention, and health promotion is done by accessing, understanding, assessing, and using appropriate health information. According to Ancker et al. (2020), the definition of health literacy is the extent to which individuals can obtain, process, and understand basic health information needed to make informed decisions.

Meanwhile, the Healthy People 2030 framework states that health literacy is the extent to which a person can find, understand, and use this information to make decisions about the health of themselves and others based on that information (US Department of Health & Human Services, 2020). Someone who has good health literacy will be able to participate in public and private dialogue about health, medicine, scientific knowledge, and cultural beliefs (Zarcadoolas et al., 2005). Based on the explanation above, health literacy emphasizes the ability of people to use information, not only to understand it.

In the research of Mosley and Taylor (2017), health literacy is an ability that nurses must possess in adapting nursing care to patients. Health literacy is the extent to which individuals can use the information studied appropriately to determine the most appropriate nursing intervention given to patients. Nurses are also expected to assess the level of health literacy of patients (Wittenberg et al., 2018a). In addition, decisions made based on health literacy are highlighted findings because being “well informed” is not just the right decision. Thus, health literacy is a person’s process of obtaining and using that information based on appropriate information in making decisions regarding the health of oneself and others.

Health literacy can apply at the individual and community levels in public health. Further links between health literacy and public health, McKenna et al. (2017) conceptualize that health literacy is a relational concept that involves how individuals interact with health and social systems. This concept is so complex that it requires a greater understanding of the context of the public health experience. The same thing was expressed by Guzys et al. (2015) defines health literacy from the perspective of public health and should emphasize the knowledge and skills needed to prevent disease and improve health in everyday life.

The definition of health literacy is evolving towards a focus on public health promotion and empowerment that allows everyone to have control over their health. Health literacy also helps identify an individual’s motivation and ability to access, understand, and use the information to promote and maintain health (Nutbeam et al., 2018). Health literacy is an essential aspect of health promotion, including environmental, political, and social aspects that can hinder or improve health outcomes (World Health Organization Regional Office for Europe, 2019). Health literacy at the community level can increase knowledge, skills, and health behaviours that result in better health impacts (Guzys et al., 2015). So, health literacy is a form of an individual, group, or community’s ability to obtain information, understand, evaluate, and apply it to overcome health-related problems. In the end, they can make health-related decisions based on the correct information.

A Determinant Factor of Health Literacy

Within the scope of nursing, health literacy skills as the basis for professional nursing practice in supporting nursing care for patients are influenced by various determinant factors. Interventions to improve health status through a good health literacy that occurs in individuals, communities, and society must consider the determinants of health literacy. According to Koduah et al. (2021), determinant factors that affect health literacy consist of demographic factors (age, gender, marital status, location of residence), socio-cultural factors (religiosity, cultural values, trust in others, group membership, income, social-economic status), and educational and professional practice factors (occupational specialization, work experience, employment status, length of study, educational attainment).

This determinant is in common with Sørensen et al. (2012), which said the predictors for health literacy are divided into personal, social-environmental, and situational factors. Individual factors include age, gender, race, socioeconomic status, education, work status, occupation, income, and knowledge. Following social and environmental factors have demographic conditions, culture, language, political power, and social systems as for the situational factors that affect health literacy, namely social support, family and groups, the use of media, and the physical environment.

Demographic or personal factors, especially age, gender, income, education, and employment status, were found to have a close relationship to determining a person’s health literacy (Ayaz-Alkaya & Terzi, 2019; Coşkun & Bebiş, 2019; M. T. Kim et al., 2020; S. Kim & Oh, 2021; Koduah et al., 2021; Munangatire et al., 2022; Wittenberg et al., 2018a). Among these individual factors, age has the closest relationship with health literacy. The higher the age, the lower the health literacy (Do et al., 2020; Liu et al., 2015; Yang et al., 2021). Likewise, Sántha’s (2021) study found that health literacy significantly correlated with age and education factors. However, in his research, these two factors are categorized into socioeconomic factors. In addition, Yang et al. (2021) said that in addition to personal factors, access to information or the use of information sources such as the internet is a factor that determines a person’s literacy. Health literacy is a concept based on the existence of the information, so access to information becomes an inseparable part of the formation of health literacy. Literacy skills will not be sufficient for someone with less access to information. This statement is supported by several studies that found that using various sources or access to information will determine a person’s level of health literacy (Ayaz-Alkaya & Terzi, 2019; S. Kim & Oh, 2021; Turan et al., 2021). Motivational factors and the individual’s ability to access information also affect health literacy (Izadirad & Zareban, 2022).

Meanwhile, Guo et al. (2021) found that sociodemographic factors (gender, education, income, and access to information) were not directly related to health literacy. Social-democratic relationships were observed through personal factors such as self-efficacy, social support, and health status. All of these individual factors have a positive relationship with health literacy. Health status in sick people is a close predictor of health literacy. Health status, disease history, disease severity, other health disorders, and the use of drugs will fundamentally affect a person’s efforts to increase or decrease health literacy (Ayaz-Alkaya & Terzi, 2019; Coşkun & Bebiş, 2019; M. T. Kim et al., 2020; S. Kim & Oh, 2021; Munangatire et al., 2022; Turan et al., 2021).

In addition to the factors mentioned above, spiritual and environmental factors also affect health literacy. Ecological aspects of the residence, education, place of work, and religious beliefs impact health literacy (Pronk et al., 2021). The study conducted by Koduah et al. (2021) found that religiosity factors affect health literacy. Nurses who have firm religious beliefs view that having health is important in their lives, so having adequate health literacy becomes an inseparable part. It is the same with the home environment (Ayaz-Alkaya & Terzi, 2019; Koduah et al., 2021; Wittenberg et al., 2018a) and the work environment (Koduah et al., 2021; Nesari et al., 2019) as nurses also determines individual health literacy and actions to increase patient health literacy. These factors will determine the health literacy of individuals, groups, or communities.

Dimensions of health literacy

Health literacy contributes to a person’s health status. Health literacy puts the health of oneself, family, and society into the context of knowledge, understanding the factors that influence it, knowing how to get it, and knowing how to use it. A person with adequate health literacy will be competent in paying attention to their health, families, and communities (Zhang et al., 2021).

From the perspective of public health, health literacy generally accommodates the concept of health through three health domains, namely health services, disease prevention, and health promotion. As expressed by Sørensen et al. (2012) regarding the conceptual model of health literacy that health literacy is a multidimensional concept and consists of different components. The health literacy model also identifies individual and system-level factors influencing a person’s literacy level. In addition, in the health literacy concept model, a pathway connects health literacy with health outcomes. The competencies needed to achieve health literacy goals include access, understanding, appraising, and applying information.

The four dimensions of health literacy mentioned above are the same as those used by Munangatire et al. (2022) in their research, which consists of access to health information, understanding health information, evaluating health information, and utilizing health information. These dimensions are used to assess health literacy in the scope of health practice in nursing.

1. Access

Access refers to seeking, finding, and obtaining information in health literacy. The ability to acquire and access knowledge depends on understanding, time, and trust. At this stage, the ability to access information must balance in measuring the accuracy of the sources of information found (Matterne et al., 2021). If the source of information accessed and obtained is inadequate or has an inappropriate tendency, it will harm understanding and making decisions at the health literacy application stage. Thus, determining the source of information is also an important factor in accessing information.

2. Understand

Understanding competence in health literacy means the ability to understand accessible health information. Understanding information depends on expectations, perceived utility, individualization of results, and interpretation of causality (Sørensen et al., 2012). Understanding of information can also be influenced by emotions, such as when people face a problem related to a deteriorating health condition or disclosure of an illness (McKenna et al., 2017).

3. Appraise

Assessment is the ability to interpret, filter, assess, and evaluate health information that has been accessed. The processing and assessment of health literacy are influenced by the complexity of the information, jargon, and partial understanding of the information. Dehghani (2021) states that the evaluation of health information is critical in applying health literacy. If the review of health information is not carried out properly, it will cause difficulties in using the information as a basis for decision-making. However, the ability to assess the information obtained is still determined by the previous stage, namely the ability to read information comprehensively.

4. Apply

Application is the competence or ability to communicate and use the information to make decisions in improving or maintaining health status. The application of health literacy to obtain effective communication depends on a thorough understanding. Information that is successfully received, understood, and evaluated regarding the truth of the information, when applied, will produce the best decision because of good news.

The health literacy process produces knowledge and skills that enable a person to achieve health goals (Matterne et al., 2021). Health literacy is a form of knowledge, competence, and motivation to access, understand, assess, and apply health information in making the right decisions in health care, disease prevention, and health promotion. However, health literacy, a complex concept that has been widely developed in various studies, has various perspectives related to its dimensions.

Several studies use the dimensions of health literacy developed by Zarcadoolas et al. (2005), namely fundamental literacy, science literacy, civic literacy, and cultural literacy (Mosley & Taylor, 2017), and the development of traditional literacy, health literacy, information literacy, scientific literacy, media literacy, and computer literacy (Coşkun & Bebiş, 2019; S. Kim & Oh, 2021) as a basis for assessing health literacy according to the research context. Fundamental literacy refers to skills and strategies that involve the ability to read, converse, write, and count (Zarcadoolas et al., 2005). Fundamental literacy is also the main aspect that affects daily life and impacts patients’ ability to interpret health information and education (Mosley & Taylor, 2017).

The second dimension is science literacy, which is fundamental knowledge of scientific concepts, understanding of technology, and technical complexity, awareness of scientific uncertainty, and acceptance of changes in science (Zarcadoolas et al., 2005). According to Mosley and Taylor (2017), low scientific literacy can cause patients to misinterpret the disease process, which has the potential to reduce their disease management ability. Understanding basic health information is necessary for managing health problems, although some medical conditions require a higher level of health literacy.

Civic literacies, which is the third dimension according to Zarcadoolas et al. (2005), are media literacy skills and awareness that individual decisions can impact public health. Meanwhile, the last dimension, namely cultural literacy, relates to recognizing and using collective beliefs, habits, broad perspectives, and social identities to interpret and act on health information (Zarcadoolas et al., 2005). Everyone needs to recognize and understand the patient’s cultural background to communicate effectively. Based on cultural literacy, an understanding of how the professional culture of health care providers and patient culture will affect communication (Mosley & Taylor, 2017).

On the other hand, Wittenberg et al. (2018a), Turan et al. (2021), and Ayaz-Alkaya & Terzi (2019), in their research, apply the dimensions of health literacy based on the scope of the problem study. The context of study includes health literacy support, perceived comport health literacy (Wittenberg et al., 2018a), individuals’ knowledge, knowledge about places of an organ in the body (Ayaz-Alkaya & Terzi, 2019), comfort and perceived skills at finding evaluating, dan applying electronic health information to health problems (Turan et al., 2021). Meanwhile, the study of Nesari et al. (2019) and Koduah et al. (Koduah et al., 2021) apply the dimensions of health literacy as an indicator in assessing health literacy based on the instrument developed by Cormier (2006). The indicators include basic facts, health literacy screening, consequences of low health literacy, written guidelines, health care materials, and evaluation of health literacy interventions.

The various dimensions of health literacy that already exist are alternative solutions to solve a problem or develop scientific concepts related to health literacy. The multidimensionality of health literacy implies that everyone who will use the health literacy approach must conduct an in-depth study first in using the dimensions of health literacy. The development of health literacy in nursing requires assessment so that the concepts used are appropriate and able to answer every problem.

Implications and role of nurses in health literacy

Health literacy has been widely recognized as a mediator between individual and social health status and health outcomes. Health literacy is the initial component of obtaining a permanent health culture and optimal health status (Barton et al., 2018). Health literacy allows a person to make a good decisions on health care, disease prevention and health promotion to maintain and improve health (Alsubaie & Salem, 2019; Guo et al., 2021). Adequate health literacy will improve healthy lifestyle behaviours and increase individual capacity to manage disease conditions (Coşkun & Bebiş, 2019; M. T. Kim et al., 2020; Mosley & Taylor, 2017).

Meanwhile, limited health literacy will affect people’s behaviour related to self-management of chronic conditions, outcomes of health efforts (Sántha, 2021), and health costs in society (Dehghani, 2021). Several studies have also revealed that inadequate health literacy can lead to poor health implications, unsuccessful preventive care, and high health care costs. Health literacy also affects the effects of social determinants of health and health status (Mantwill et al., 2015; Rasu et al., 2015). This condition shows that inadequate health literacy will lead to health disparities.

The health literacy gap has a massive impact on overall health disparities. Efforts to reduce health literacy gaps are essential to reduce health disparities, especially at the community or community level (Gómez et al., 2021; Pronk et al., 2021). Health literacy affects a person’s health attitudes and behaviour, as in the research by Silva & Santos (2021), which found that health literacy has a relationship with knowledge and attitudes toward preventing Covid-19. The better health literacy, the better the perspective on preventing disease Health literacy is not passive but a form of participatory ability and foundation in positive behaviour change. Individuals with an adequate level of health literacy can take responsibility for their health and the well-being of their families and communities (Pitts & Freeman, 2021). Therefore, efforts to strengthen health literacy can enhance primary health conditions at the individual and community levels. Increasing health literacy will also improve overall health and welfare status.

Low levels of health literacy are also associated with poor health (Balmer et al., 2020). The application of health literacy that is carried out at any time and in all patient care settings will impact achieving client empowerment, engagement, activation, and optimal health outcomes (Loan et al., 2018). Nurses have a significant role in educating patients about health information and health promotion (Mosley & Taylor, 2017). Providing health literacy support to patients is also a nurse’s core skill (Wittenberg et al., 2018b). In carrying out this role, nurses need to have a broad understanding of health literacy.

In nursing, health literacy is an essential mediator in communication strategies for all clients. Clients cannot fully participate in their health care or make appropriate health decisions without accurate information for their health literacy needs (Ballard & Hill, 2016). Nurses as health workers who have a closer relationship with clients can become facilitators to meet these health literacy needs through health education or health promotion activities.

A nurse who plays a role in improving health literacy must understand the extent of health literacy skills and the level of understanding that the patient has of a disease or problem. Sometimes nurses often overestimate the client’s level of health literacy, report using their feelings, and only rely on the client’s level of education as an indicator in concluding the client’s literacy ability (Dickens et al., 2013; Macabasco-O’Connell & Fry-Bowers, 2011; Parnell, 2014). That actions taken by the nurse became problematic.

Nurses cannot assume a person’s literacy level is only seen from external appearances such as age, education, or socioeconomic status. When the nurse provides information to the client, the nurse must be careful in interpreting the client’s body language movements, such as a nod of the head, lest this is interpreted as an indication that the patient has understood the information provided (Parnell, 2014). As previously explained, health literacy is not a simple concept of understanding but something that must assess carefully, persistently, and intensely. Health literacy that is studied inadequately will eventually become an obstacle to health literacy for clients. As stated by Cohen et al. (2013), in ensuring understanding and overcoming the problems of health literacy barriers, nurses must carry out adequate assessments to assess the client’s level of knowledge, emotional reactions to information, and involvement from outside or other health teams that can provide support.

Wittenberg et al. (2018b) provide several recommendations in assessing health literacy in individuals or groups, or communities who experience health literacy barriers, including 1) nurses must understand the beliefs and cultural norms of clients; 2) repetition of information explanations or providing information more technically adapted to the cultural approach of the client; 3) nurses must be able to observe verbal and nonverbal cues, and must be careful with medical terms that may be new to clients, or use simple language in providing information; and 4) someone who has a language barrier can involve a translator. Therefore, the ability of nurses to assess patient understanding and address challenges related to health literacy needs is vital to providing quality nursing care so literacy can improve.