Monitoring One Heart to Help Two: Heart Rate Variability and Resting Heart Rate using Wearable Technology in Active Women Across the Perinatal Period

Introduction

Despite data that indicate a myriad of benefits of activity during pregnancy¹, qualitative evidences suggests that there are consistent cultural expectations that pregnant women “should sit down and slow down”.² These cultural expectations seem to be internalized with only 3-15% of those pregnant meeting current physical activity guidelines compared to 24-26% of non-pregnant individuals.³ Currently, based on clear evidence that physical activity and exercise in pregnancy is safe, the American College of Obstetrics and Gynecology (ACOG) recommends that women with uncomplicated pregnancies initiate or continue physical activity.¹ They also advise that women who intend to get pregnant but do not have healthy lifestyles should focus on adopting them when possible prior to pregnancy. However, pregnant woman seeking advice from an obstetrician regarding physical activity in pregnancy may still receive conflicting answers. In a survey by Bauer et al., the majority of physicians surveyed were not familiar with the most recent ACOG guidelines.⁴ While the establishment of guidelines regarding the safety of physical activity in pregnancy has been agreed upon by leading organizations,⁵ many studies of exercise in pregnancy rely on retrospective data collected postpartum.

Wearable technology is an increasingly popular area of fitness tracking and in vivo data collection that opens doors for novel data collection in the area of pregnancy fitness.⁶ The WHOOP® strap (Strap 2.0; WHOOP, Inc., Boston, MA, USA) is a commercially available wearable device that provides continuous physiologic data monitoring and training recommendations based on proprietary scientific research.⁷ WHOOP® uses heart rate variability (HRV), along with resting heart rate (RHR) and sleep patterns to determine readiness for activity.⁸ HRV measures the irregularity of heart beat rhythm over time and is considered a low-cost, noninvasive measurement of overall competence of the autonomic nervous system.⁹ RHR measures the number of times a heart beats every 60 seconds at rest and is widely regarded as a measure of cardiovascular fitness.¹⁰ Combined, higher HRV and lower RHR represent higher levels of fitness. When evaluated together, HRV and RHR provide important insights regarding fitness and recovery levels of athletes.¹¹

Previous studies have relied on intermittent measurement of autonomic responses using 24-hour holter monitoring or shorter HRV recordings.^12,13 Using 18-minute HRV recordings at 28, 32 and 36 weeks, May et al. found that regardless of maternal exercise, heart rate increased throughout pregnancy.¹² However, exercise during pregnancy resulted in lower maternal RHR and increased HRV, which indicate improvements in autonomic control.¹²

Limited research has started to use continuous monitoring of different physiological variables with wearable technology during pregnancy.^{6, 14, 15} However, these are limited by short length of monitoring, lack of monitoring of both HRV and RHR, and/or limited participants (case study).⁶ This is a burgeoning field of study and the potential to increase the time of follow-up during the perinatal period, measure HRV and RHR, and include an adequate sample of participants provides the potential to inform future research and current clinical practice.

The current study is designed to explore and describe the autonomic response in physically active women prior to, during, and after pregnancy when monitored in a continuous fashion. Continuous monitoring of physiologic data provides a novel view into cardiovascular workload and capacity during pregnancy. We had two main goals for this study. Our first aim was to use descriptive analyses to examine HRV and RHR changes during pregnancy in a sample of healthy women who were physical activity at least three days a week prior to pregnancy. Our second aim was to understand the relationship between increased activity during pregnancy and variations in HRV and RHR. We hypothesized that increasing activity would positively impact changes in HRV and RHR during pregnancy.

Methods

Data Analysis

Data analyses were conducted in SAS 9.4.¹⁷ Descriptive statistics are reported as frequencies and valid percentages of categorical variables, and mean, standard deviation, minimum and maximum values for continuous variables. Data were summarized by participant and by week for some descriptive analysis. Linear mixed models were used to model the longitudinal data. After assumptions were checked and found satisfactory, a variety of models were tested, including random intercept, random slope, both random intercept and slope, along with continuous (e.g., day to delivery) and categorical (e.g., trimester) time effects. Time was restricted to 43 weeks prior to birth and 8 weeks post-partum for the models, as most participants had data for this time-period. Splines were fitted for non-linear patterns with the continuous time fixed effects. The best fitting models were selected via lowest Akaike information criterion (AIC). Kuder-Richardson degree of freedom correction was used for all models. All available data was used via Restricted Maximum Likelihood (REML) method. The best fitting model included a random intercept and random continuous time slope (days to delivery), with a variance components covariance matrix and two splines set at different points for the two outcomes. A series of three models are presented for each of the two outcomes: Model 1: days until delivery only; Model 2: moderators for total activity minutes per day; Model 3: moderators for moderate/vigorous activity minutes per day. Fixed effects estimates along with standard errors, df, t-value and p-value are presented for each model.

Results

Changes during Pregnancy

Based on WHOOP® data, activity levels decreased over the course of the pregnancy from almost 28 minutes of logged daily activity pre-pregnancy to 14 minutes by the third trimester (Table 1). There were also decreases in HRV and increases in RHR by trimester. Logged number of daily activity minutes was strongly correlated with moderate/vigorous daily activity minutes (r=0.82, p < 0.0001), and both indicators were correlated with the daily available strain score (activity r = 0.42, p < 0.0001; mod/vig r = 0.56, p < 0.0001).

View this table:

• View inline
• View popup
• Download powerpoint

Table 1:

Descriptive statistics for variables of interest; n=18 across 7,305 days of data.

Cardiovascular fitness decreased throughout pregnancy until 7-8 weeks prior to delivery, and then rapidly improved through and post-birth (Figures 1 and 2). A small reduction in HRV and increase in RHR can be seen in Figures 1 and 2 around the point of conception.

• Download figure
• Open in new tab

Figure 1:

Weeks until birth, with splines indicated by a dotted line and referent lines included for the starts of trimester of pregnancy for average heart rate variability (n=18).

• Download figure
• Open in new tab

Figure 2:

Weeks until birth, with splines indicated by a dotted line and referent lines included for the starts of trimester of pregnancy for average resting heart rate (n=18).

Discussion

The 2018 U.S. Department of Health and Human Services Physical Activity Guidelines for Americans state that women who engage in high-intensity aerobic activity or are otherwise physically active prior to pregnancy can continue these activities during pregnancy and into the postpartum period. The report also recommends that women exercise at least 150 minutes per week during pregnancy and in postpartum.¹⁸ Physical activity during pregnancy is associated with lower HR and higher HRV in both the mothers and the fetus, when compared to pregnant women who are not physically active,^{19, 20} along with increased stroke volume and increased oxygen uptake.^{21, 22} Previous research has shown that RHR increases by 3-5% during the first semester, 10-15% during the second trimester, and 15-20% in the third trimester, and returns to pre-pregnancy values within 3-6 months postpartum. ¹

In this study, we used continuous monitoring during pregnancy as well as pre-pregnancy and postpartum data to define the physiologic changes that occur with HRV and RHR. As defined in previous studies, HRV decreased per trimester when reviewed as a whole.^{13, 23}

However, in this sample of healthy and active women, cardiovascular health generally decreased over the course of the pregnancy until roughly 49 days (7 weeks) prior to birth. At that time, cardiovascular health indicators rapidly improved until post birth even beyond pre-pregnancy levels.

In this sample of generally active women, more activity minutes per day mitigated some of the negative impact of pregnancy on cardiovascular health and helped with improvements post-pregnancy. The slight worsening in cardiovascular health in the 49 days prior to birth through the date of birth may be related to the participants’ improved cardiovascular health prior to that point. This effect was stronger for general activity minutes than for moderate/vigorous minutes, suggesting the amount of activity may be more beneficial than the type of activity.

Currently, obstetricians do not consistently provide clear exercise recommendations for their patients, especially those who are sedentary (McGee et al., 2018). The findings of this study indicate any type of activity is beneficial to overall cardiovascular health during pregnancy.

There are significant clinical implications for these findings due to the ease of integrating additional minutes of activity rather than increasingly rigorous or different types of exercise. Obstetrician’s most limited exercise recommendations have been on resistance training, maximum heart rate during exercise, and third trimester exercise (McGee et al., 2018), so this allows for easier recommendations to be disseminated while still improving patient’s cardiovascular health.

Conclusions

In summary, this data has strong implications for all pregnant women. In contrast to previous literature that examined cardiovascular health at discrete timepoints, our daily data demonstrates that there is a sharp improvement in cardiovascular health in all women with uncomplicated term pregnancies prior to birth. Consistent with other data, but in extensive detail, we demonstrate that pregnant women who were able to be more active had consistently improved RHR and HRV particularly during the first few trimesters of pregnancy and during the post-pregnancy recovery period. Using this data from uncomplicated term pregnancies, future studies can evaluate HRV and RHR in women who are not currently active as well as in women at high risk for complications.

Funding statement

Research reported in this publication was supported in part by the National Institute of General Medical Sciences of the National Institutes of Health under Award Number 5U54GM104942-05. The content is solely the responsibility of the authors and does not necessarily represent the official views of the National Institutes of Health.