ABSTRACT
Objective We aimed to evaluate the quality of a multinational intensive care unit (ICU) network of registries of critically ill patients established in seven Asian low and middle income countries (LMICs).
Methods The Critical Care Asia federated registry platform enables ICUs to collect clinical, outcome and process data for aggregate and unit-level analysis. The evaluation used the standardised criteria of the Directory of Clinical Databases (DoCDat) and a framework for data quality assurance in medical registries. Six reviewers assessed structure, coverage, reliability and validity of the ICU registry data. Case mix and process measures on patient episodes from June to December 2020 were analysed.
Results Data on 20,507 consecutive patient episodes from 97 ICUs in Afghanistan, Bangladesh, India, Malaysia, Nepal, Pakistan and Vietnam were included. The quality level achieved according to the ten prespecified DoCDat criteria was high (average score 3.4 out of 4) as was the structural and organizational performance -- comparable to ICU registries in high-income countries. Identified strengths were types of variables included, reliability of coding, data completeness and validation. Potential improvements include extension of national coverage.
Conclusion The Critical Care Asia platform evaluates well using standardised frameworks for data quality and equally to registries in resource-rich settings.
Funding This work was undertaken as part of the existing Wellcome Innovations Flagship award, Collaboration for Research, Improvement and Training in Critical CARE in ASIA (ref. 215522/Z/19/Z). The funder had no role in the decision to publish or in the preparation of this manuscript.
Competing Interest Statement
The authors have declared no competing interest.
Funding Statement
Funding This work was undertaken as part of the existing Wellcome Innovations Flagship award, Collaboration for Research, Improvement and Training in Critical CARE in ASIA (ref. 215522/Z/19/Z). The funder had no role in the decision to publish or in the preparation of this manuscript.
Author Declarations
I confirm all relevant ethical guidelines have been followed, and any necessary IRB and/or ethics committee approvals have been obtained.
Yes
The details of the IRB/oversight body that provided approval or exemption for the research described are given below:
Oxford Tropical Research Ethical Committee (OxTREC) exemption from ethical review on 16 June 2020
All necessary patient/participant consent has been obtained and the appropriate institutional forms have been archived.
Yes
I understand that all clinical trials and any other prospective interventional studies must be registered with an ICMJE-approved registry, such as ClinicalTrials.gov. I confirm that any such study reported in the manuscript has been registered and the trial registration ID is provided (note: if posting a prospective study registered retrospectively, please provide a statement in the trial ID field explaining why the study was not registered in advance).
Yes
I have followed all appropriate research reporting guidelines and uploaded the relevant EQUATOR Network research reporting checklist(s) and other pertinent material as supplementary files, if applicable.
Yes
Footnotes
Collaboration for Research, Implementation and Training in Critical Care - Asia Investigators
COLLABORATORS: Collaborators are listed by registry in alphabetical order (Site leads are in bold):
AFGHANISTAN: Ahmad Seyar Quraishi, Meharnegar Haqyar Mohammadi, Ahmad Zekria Sherzai (Wazir Akbar Khan Hospital, Kabul), Ghulam Rahim Awab, Noorullah Ahmadzai, Guldad Khan Safi (Nangarhar Regional Hospital, Jalalabad), Mirwais Azizi (Ali Jenah Hospital, Kabul), Asilah Hedayat (Herat Regional Hospital, Herat); Naseebullah Barekzai, Dawood Safi (Indira Gandhi Children’s Hospital, Kabul).
BANGLADESH: Aniruddha Ghose, Ranjan Kumar Nath, Selim Kashem Chowdhury, Smriti Kona Debi, Kamrun Akter, Safiqul Mostafa Chy (Chattogram Medical College Hospital, Chattogram).
INDIA (Indian Registry of IntenSive care -- IRIS): Devachandran Jayakumar, Suresh Babu Masilamani (Apollo Speciality Hospital, Chennai); Bharath Kumar, Augustian James, Nagarajan Ramakrishnan, Ramesh Venkataraman, Lakshmi Ranganathan (Apollo Main Hospital, Chennai); Meghena Mathew, Revathi Kandeepan (Apollo First Med Hospital, Chennai); Ebenezer Rabingrarajan, Madhu Shree, Usha Rani Chandramohan (Apollo Speciality Hospital, Vanagaram); Jaganathan Selvanayagam, Thirumalai Sambath (Mehta Hospital, Chennai); Mathew Pulicken, Milan Mathew (Pushpagiri Medical College Hospital, Kerala); Rakesh Lakshmappa, Karthik Shivani Lokeshappa (Nanjappa Multispecialty Hospital, Karnataka); Raymond Savio, Sristi Patodia, Premnath Balakrishnan (Apollo Proton Cancer Center); Kishore Mangal, Disha Chandel (Eternal Hospital, Jaipur Rajasthan); Deepak Vijayan, Krishna Priya, (KIMS, Kerala); Rajyabardhan Patnaik, Kasi Chinni Krishna (ISPAT General Hospital, Rourkela); Kavita Kamineni, Saradha Chirravuri (ABC Hospital, Visakhapatnam); Swagatha Tripathi, Kasturi Sanyal (AIIMS, Bhuvaneshwar); Zubair Mohamed, Anna Paul (Amrita Institute of Medical Sciences).
NEPAL (Nepal Intensive Care registry Foundation -- NICRF): Diptesh Aryal, Sanjeet K Shrestha, Kishor Khanal, Ashim Regmi, Namrata Rai, Kanchan Koirala, Kaveri Thapa, Krisha Dheke, Manisha Maharjan (Nepal Mediciti Hospital, Lalitpur); Subhash Acharya, Kabita Sitoula, Asmita Pokhrel, Namrata Shrestha, Saraswoti Sharma, Bimala Make, Arati Phuyal, Radhika Maharjan, Sabi Bajracharya, Roshni Thapa, Binita Bhattarai (Tribhuvan University Teaching Hospital, Kathmandu); Sabin Koirala, Hem Paneru, Sujata Chauhan, Angela Lamichhane, Alina Lamichhane, Sangita G.C, Swastika Phuyal, Crystal Maharjan, Anusha Subedi, Bini Kayastha, Kabita Khadka, Rakshya Karki Pratibha, Paudel XX (Hospital for Advanced Medicine and Surgery HAMS, Kathmandu); Sushil Khanal, Samina Amatya, Pujan Rajbhandary, Bina Bhattarai, Sabita Shrestha Sharmila Mali XX (Grande International Hospital); Basanta Gauli, Nisha Bhandari, Babita Ghimire, Asmita Kaini (Chitwan Medical College, Chitwan); Bipin Karki, Pramesh Shrestha, Roshni Karki, Sabina Dhakal, Mandira Thapa, Sarita Tamang (Om Hospital, Kathmandu); Shubha Kalyan Shrestha, Roshni Kafle, Kalpana Gurung (Karuna Hospital, Kathmandu); Sanjay Lakhey, Anita Bashya, Prajina Malla, Jeeya Deuja (B&B Hospital, Lalitpur); Anand Thakur, Radhika Maharjan, Sachita Maharjan, Subina Maharjan Yashu (Nidan Hospital, Lalitpur); Raju Shrestha, Pratima Sigdel, Merina Pradhan (B & C Hospital, Lalitpur).
MALAYSIA: Mohd Basri Mat-Nor, Azrina Md Ralib, Nurhafizah Zarudin, Fatimah Mohamad (IIUMMC - International Islamic University Malaysia Medical Center, Kuala Lumpur); Mohd Zulfakar Bin Maslan, Wan Fadzlina Wan Ahmad Shukeri, Amir Asyraf (Hospital Universiti Sains Malaysia, Kota Bharu); Noor Airini Ibrahim, Noor Fazlina (Hospital Pengajar UPM, Pengajar); Dr Mohd Shahnaz Hasan, Dr Nor’azim Mohd Yunos, Dr Rafidah Atan, Yip Hing Wa (Universiti Malaya Medical Center, Kuala Lumpur).
PAKISTAN (Pakistan Registry of Intensive Care -- PRICE): Ashok Kumar, Mukesh Kumar, Quratul Ain Khan, Osama Khalid, Ali Raza, Ali Abbas, Akash Thakrani, Noor Hassan, Ilyas Shehzad, Samad Ali (Ziauddin Group of Hospitals, Karachi); Dr Attaur Rehman, Amir Khan, Ahmed Zia, Farhan Khan (Patel Hospital, Karachi); Nawal Salahuddin, Amin Khawaja, Mohammad Imran, Sobia Masood, Vinod Kumar (National Institute of Cardiovascular Diseases, Karachi); Tanvir Alam, Noor Hassan (Civil Hospital, Karachi); Nadeem Muneer, Vinod Kumar (Jinnah Post-Graduate Medical Center, Karachi); Aneela Altaf Kidwai, Aftab Ahmed, Amir Khan (Abbasi Shaheed Hospital, Karachi); Rashid Nasim Khan, Jhonsan Shahzad (Darul Sehat Hospital, Karachi); Saeeda Haider, Junaid Patel, Fivzia Herekar, Arther John, Yasir Rehman (The Indus Hospital, Karachi); Fakhir Raza Haidri, Fawadur Rehman, (SIUT, Karachi); Muhammad Nasir Khoso, Noor Hassan (South City Hospital, Karachi); Saleh Khaskheli, Muhammad Ibrahim (Peoples Medical University, Nawabshah); Kashif Memon, Mohsin Ali (Liaquat University Hospital, Hyderabad); Maqsood Meher, Afzal Ahmed (GMMM Teaching Hospital, Sukkur); Sayed Muneeb Ali, Rana Imran Sikandar, Imtiaz Ali Shah (Pakistan Institute of Medical Sciences, Islamabad); Liaquat Ali, Muhammad Ashraf Zia, Moazzam Tarar, Ahmed Ranjha, Basit Ali, Shahryar Maqsood (Jinnah Hospital, Lahore); Ahmed Farooq, Shahbaz Ikram (Doctors Hospital, Lahore); Arshad Taqi, Junaid Anwar (National Hospital & Medical Center, Lahore); Jodat Saleem, Irfan malik, Rehan Niazi, Shahryar Maqsood (Lahore General Hospital, Lahore); Naseem Ali Shah (Hameed Latif Hospital, Lahore); Kamran Cheema, Mazhar Ali Naqvi, Basit Ali (Services Hospital, Lahore); Iqbal Hussain, Mobin Chaudhary, Muddasir Qadir (Pakistan Kidney and Liver Institute, Lahore); Sairah Sadaf, Anjum Saleem (Sheikh Zayed Medical College, Rahim Yar Khan); Muhammad Hayat, Arslan Rahatullah, Muhammad Kamran, Farman Ali Khan, Imran Khan (North West General Hospital, Peshawar); Muhammad Sheharyar, Sajjad Orakzai, Imran Khan, Zafar Iqbal Khatak (Lady Reading Hospital, Peshawar); Imran ul Haq, Farman Ali Khan (Khyber Teaching Hospital, Peshawar).
VIETNAM: Vu Dinh Phu, Dong Phu Khiem, Pham Van Phuc, Doan Duy Thanh, Trinh Lan Huong, Dang Van Duong, Tran van Kien, Mac Duy Hung, Vo Duc Linh (National Hospital for Tropical Diseases, Hanoi); Nguyen Thien Binh, Nguyen Thi Thu Van, Vy Thi Thu Luan, Lien Thi Xuan Nga, Nguyen Thi Dieu Vy, Vuong My Dung, Cao Thi Lan Huong, Ho Ngoc Bao, Huynh Nhat Anh, Nguyen Hoang Huy, Truong Huynh Tan Phu, Nguyen Hong Ngoc, Tran Thi Kim Anh, Doan Minh Nhut (Trung Vuong Hospital, Ho Chi Minh); Dinh Minh Duc, Vo Thi Dung, Huynh Nguyet, Truong Dai Lan Ngoc, Nguyen Thuy Hang, Nguyen Tan Khanh (Dong Thap Hospital, Dong Thap); Duong Bich Thuy, (Hospital for Tropical Diseases, Ho Chi Minh City); Yen Lam Minh, Doan Bui Xuan Thy, Tran Minh Duc, Louise Thwaites, Nguyen Thanh Ngoc, Luu Phuoc An (Oxford University Clinical Research Unit).
NICS MORU Crit Care Asia Network Registry Coordination Team: Udara Attanayake, Sri Darshana, Kaumali Gimhani, Judy Ann Gitahi, Pramodya Ishani, Chamira Kodippily, Issrah Jawad, Shiekh Mohiuddin, Upule Pabasara, Dilanthi Priyadarshani, Disna Pujika, Aasiyah Rashan, Sumayyah Rashan, Thalha Rashan, Shoba Sathasivam, Timo Tolppa, Ishara Udayanga.
Data Availability
Data on which the scoring was performed is available upon request to CCA coordination and acceptance by individual National Registries.