Abstract
Introduction Conventional teaching and learning methods have been seen to fail to assure achievement of competencies in male bladder catherization in the Indian Medical Graduate (IMG) with wide variation noted in competencies. This could be remedied by introduction of Structured training methods.
Aims and Objective The study aimed to investigate DOAP method of training in a Skill Lab against training through a Structured Educational Video (SEV) with the objective of comparing their efficacy in training Final MBBS Students in the psychomotor skill of performing male bladder catheterisation.
Material & Methods Final MBBS students fulfilling selection criteria were randomly allocated into two comparable groups. One group underwent Skill lab training using DOAP method while the other group underwent training using a SEV by the same instructor. CRRI interns, regularly performing MBC at work by virtue of conventional training, with 6-8 months experience formed a control group. All participants underwent assessment of skill in MBC by skill lab OSCE evaluation, by assessors who were blinded to the participant’s method of training. Data was recorded and analysed using standard statistical software. Trial evaluation from the trial groups was obtained using Survey monkey tool.
Observation There was no statistically significant difference in the ability of DOAP group or SEV group in being able to safely perform MBC though a higher level of confidence was expressed with their training by DOAP group. Both trial groups statistically outperformed the control group.
Conclusion Structured training assures competence. Video-assisted Training produces comparable results though DOAP method is preferred by students. A combination of the techniques may facilitate optimal training.
Competing Interest Statement
The authors have declared no competing interest.
Clinical Trial
The study was performed as a mandated research project as part of the 1-year Advanced course in Medical Education administered by the National Medical Council through its nodal centre in Kottayam, Kerala, India. Study was registered and approved by Institutional review board & Institutional Ethics committee: IRB Approval Date: 29/11/2019 IEC Protocol Number: MOSC/IEC/398/2019. My project was a simulation based educational research. Though it involved human volunteers, there was only an educational intervention to facilitate the learning of a bed side skill. No medications or physical interventions were involved. The outcome measure was based on ability to demonstrate the skill learnt in a simulation lab model and hence did not involve any direct impact on humans or patients. The training or absence of the same would have no impact on the formal academic assessment or progress of the volunteers outside of the trial environment. Fairness to the volunteers was ensured by offering each group the opportunity to experience the other educational intervention after assessment and feedback was complete. We believed therefore that the education research as described did not qualify as a clinical trial and hence registration as a clinical trial was not felt mandatory. The IRB & IEC permitted me to proceed with my work. I was under the impression then, that registration of such research though possible was not considered mandatory. Clinical Trials Registry of India unfortunately does not allow retrospective registrations.
Funding Statement
The team did not receive any monetary funding. Acknowledgement to Mr Kalesh Karun, Biostatician, MOSC Medical College Hospital for help with Statistical analysis. Acknowledgement to administration of MOSC Medical College, for permitting use of Skill Lab and premises. Acknowledgement to my fellow learners of the Advanced Course in Medical Education: ACME Batch 2019B & the faculty of the National Medical Council Nodal center, Kottayam, Kerala for guidance & peer support. Acknowledgement to Dean: Dr KK Divaker. Medical Superintendent: Dr Sojan Ipe for institutional support. My surgical Colleagues: Dr Vergis, Dr Vigy, Dr Satish, Dr Shal & Dr Koruth for peer reviewing the Strutured video & support for the study; IRB in-charge: Dr Sara, IEC in-charge: Dr Sandhya Kurup for guidance. Skill Lab nurse: Br. Yaldho; Our Interns: Batch of 2014 Our Students: Batch of 2015 for agreeing to participate in the study. Department Clerk: Ms Sini for admin support. Sister In-charge of Operation theatre: Ms Anuja.
Author Declarations
I confirm all relevant ethical guidelines have been followed, and any necessary IRB and/or ethics committee approvals have been obtained.
Yes
The details of the IRB/oversight body that provided approval or exemption for the research described are given below:
IRB Approval Date: 29/11/2019 IEC Protocol Number: MOSC/IEC/398/2019 Institutional Review Board & Ethics Committee. MOSC Medical College Hospital. Ernakulam. Kerala. India. 682311
All necessary patient/participant consent has been obtained and the appropriate institutional forms have been archived.
Yes
I understand that all clinical trials and any other prospective interventional studies must be registered with an ICMJE-approved registry, such as ClinicalTrials.gov. I confirm that any such study reported in the manuscript has been registered and the trial registration ID is provided (note: if posting a prospective study registered retrospectively, please provide a statement in the trial ID field explaining why the study was not registered in advance).
Yes
I have followed all appropriate research reporting guidelines and uploaded the relevant EQUATOR Network research reporting checklist(s) and other pertinent material as supplementary files, if applicable.
Yes
Data Availability
The author holds the data pertaining to the results of the study.
Abbreviations
- SEV
- (Structured Educational Video)
- DOAP
- (Demonstrate, Observe, Assist, Perform)
- CRRI
- (Compulsory Residential Rotating Internship)
- MBC
- (Male bladder catheterisation)
- IMG
- (Indian Medical Graduate)
