Plant power? A systematic review of the effects of plant-based diets on people with mental illness

Introduction

Plant-based diets and vegetarian diets are terms used interchangeably for a group of diets which exclude or minimise the consumption of meat, including vegan diets which also exclude eggs and dairy. There is evidence that suggests that plant-based and vegetarian diets have beneficial effects on physical health, which include reduced risk of developing diabetes and cardiovascular disease, improved diabetic control and weight loss in patients with type 2 diabetes, and improved survival outcomes for people with colorectal cancer [1–7]. A recent systematic review found evidence for the positive impact of a plant-based diet on metabolic measures in health and disease [8]. This evidence has been translated into clinical and public health practice, with plant-based dietary patterns incorporated into guidelines for sustainable health and wellbeing [9–11], as well as Canadian and American guidelines for the management of type 2 diabetes [12,13].

The World Health Organisation predicted in 2001 that 450 million people were affected by a mental health condition globally [14]. A more recent review suggests that mental disorders and addictive disorders combined affect about one billion people globally [15]. Each year about 20% of the English population will experience a common mental disorder, yet perhaps only one in three will access help [16,17].

People with severe mental illness are more likely to have other chronic health conditions and die 15-20 years younger than the general population [18,19]. Those with mental health disorders experience higher rates of overweight and obesity than the general population due to a range of risk factors; medication, poor diet, high alcohol intake and inactive lifestyle [18]. Whilst not the only risk factor, medication can play a big part in weight gain: many medications used in psychiatry are associated with weight gain, particularly antipsychotics [20].

When people are started on antipsychotics, they tend to experience excessive and rapid weight gain [21–23]. The higher rates of abdominal obesity, metabolic syndrome, hypertriglyceridemia, diabetes and hypertension contribute to the life expectancy gap [24–27]. Whether or not plant-based diets can have positive health effects for people with severe and enduring mental illness is not known, but has been posited as worthy of exploration [28].

Whole (unprocessed) plant-based foods may be able to promote psychological wellbeing and reduce the risk of developing anxiety and depressive symptoms in the general population according to evidence from a range of study types [29–36]. However, a recently published systematic review highlights that the evidence for mental effects of a plant-based diet in the general population remains inconclusive [8]. A recent randomised controlled trial found that a healthful dietary pattern (plant foods with lean meats and low-fat dairy) could improve depressive symptoms for people with major depressive disorders, who were previously consuming an unhealthy diet [35]. This suggests that dietary interventions may support improved mental health outcomes for the population with a mental illness. Dietary interventions could be a low cost, public health intervention with potential benefits for mental health but also on physical health co-morbidities. As such, this is an important topic for consideration from both a clinical psychology and public health perspective.

Therefore, we conducted a systematic review of the literature to determine the benefits and risks of plant-based diets to people with mental illness and mental health conditions.

Methods

Results

Systematic search results

The database searches identified 850 records, 588 after duplicates were removed (Figure 1). No further results were identified from grey literature searches. Following title and abstract screen, 41 articles were included in the full review. All but one were ineligible, even with the widened inclusion criteria for the intervention.

• Download figure
• Open in new tab

Figure 1: Preferred Reporting Items for Systematic Review and Meta-analyses (PRISMA) flow diagram

From: Moher D, Liberati A, Tetzlaff J, Altman DG, The PRISMA Group (2009). Preferred Reporting Items for Systematic Reviews and Meta-Analyses: The PRISMA Statement. PLoS Med 6(7): e1000097. doi:10.1371/journal.pmed1000097

For more information, visit www.prisma-statement.org.

The included study was of a 12 week, non-randomised, non-controlled diet and lifestyle intervention [38]. The extracted data is shown in Table 2. The study included 500 men and women with a diagnosis of chronic moderate to severe depression and anxiety. The diet component of the intervention was described as an anti-inflammatory plant-based diet with 70% raw foods, and no animal products. This was combined with a number of other components including juicing, exercise, mindfulness and environmental hygiene. Many outcomes were measured, but the key mental health outcomes were that 62% reported large improvement or complete remission of depression symptoms, 59% of anxiety symptoms. In terms of physical health, the key outcomes were average weight loss of 5.7lbs during the trial, increasing to 15.0lbs at six month follow up. However, 66.8% of the participations dropped out of the study, largely within the first two weeks and mostly because they found the diet and behaviour modification too rigorous. The results were reported as per protocol, rather than by intention to treat. The study was assessed to be of serious risk of bias.

View this table:

• View inline
• View popup
• Download powerpoint

Table 2: Characteristics of studies in the systematic review

Discussion

Given the increasing evidence base and guidance which advocates for plant-based diets to improve health outcomes in the general population [1–13], there is a concerning lack of evidence about the potential impact of plant-based diets on outcomes in people with mental health conditions. Our systematic review found just one study. While the results of this study found a plant-based diet (in a combined lifestyle intervention) had a positive impact on symptoms of people with major depressive disorder, the study was assessed as having serious risk of bias and the singular study means there is no data to synthesise.

There is some evidence of the impact of diet on the outcomes of people with mental health conditions. A randomised controlled trial found improvement in symptoms for people with major depressive disorder eating poor diets, who were subsequently helped to eat diets of whole, unprocessed, mostly plant-based foods, which included meat and dairy [39]. However, it is hard to know whether or not it was the whole plant foods which had the positive impact, or if including animal products had any bearing on this result. The diet recommended in this study aligns with the EAT-Lancet commission [11].

Although there is almost no research looking at the impact of exclusively plant-based diets on outcomes in people with mental ill health, there is some evidence for the impact of such diets on mental health and psychological wellbeing outcomes in the general population. Trials have suggested that different forms of plant-based diets (vegan and low fat, whole food diets) can lead to improvements in psychological wellbeing or positive impacts on mental health [31,36,40,41]. Further, the risk of developing depressive symptoms or major depressive episodes have been found to be inversely related to fruit and vegetable consumption and Mediterranean diets [29,30,42].

However, other evidence contradicts these findings and suggest that vegetarian diets may increase the risk of depressive symptoms demonstrating the lack of clarity even within the general population. Data from the Austrian health interview survey suggests that vegetarians are more likely to experience a mental health problem, than non-vegetarians [43]. Although questions have been raised about the potential for reverse causality or other confounding variables [44]. Some data suggests that vegetarian diets have no impact on mental health in Western populations [44], but can increase risk of anxiety or depressive symptoms in populations where vegetarianism is a consequence of economic restrictions rather than a positive health choice [45].

While it is generally accepted that diet does affect mental health [43], the current evidence is unable to provide clarity. Despite the lack of evidence, it remains plausible that diets of whole foods, which contain little or no processed foods, such as the Mediterranean diet, are likely to have a beneficial impact to reduce the risk of developing depressive symptoms, and contribute to recovering from depressive disorders. However, this needs further research, given the increasing evidence of the benefit of whole food plant-based diets on physical health [1–8], and the increase in people adopting vegan diets in developed countries. Britain’s vegan population has reportedly quadrupled between 2014 and 2019 to 600,000 [46]. Interest in vegan diets was recently demonstrated by analysis of google searches since 2004, which highlight a rapid growth in searches using the term “vegan” in Germany, the UK and the USA.[8]

What evidence that is available is not without its own limitations. Many studies which have looked at the effects of diet on mental health are relatively small, study a defined population (making generalisability difficult), and are open to many potential confounding factors, such a social norms, cultural influences, quality and type of foods consumed (both plant-based and animal-based).

There is significant variety in dietary patterns within groups such as ‘vegan’, ‘vegetarian’ and ‘omnivores’, making like-for-like comparisons difficult. It is possible to follow vegan and vegetarian diets which are composed of entirely processed foods with no fruit and vegetables, which would not be as healthy as a whole food plant based diet. Similarly, a diet which is composed of mostly whole plant-based foods with small amounts of lean meat is likely to be more beneficial for health than one without whole foods. These variations make comparisons of diets under broad headings difficult. There may be confounding effects from multiple other unknown sources also, such as pesticide use.

We must also be cautious using the current evidence base which focuses on depressive and anxiety symptoms of the general population, rather than those people suffering with mood disorders and anxiety disorders. There also seems to be a significant lack of research on the effects of dietary patterns on other mental disorders.

Given that there is increasing evidence for inflammatory processes in the aetiology of mental health conditions, [47,48] and that plant-based foods are considered as having a low dietary inflammatory index,[49,50] the interplay between plant-based diets, inflammation and mental illness requires further exploration. It is imperative to explore if intervening on a pro-inflammatory Western diet will have a positive impact on mental health.

Conclusion

We have conducted a comprehensive systematic review to explore the impact of plant-based diets on mental illness, which is the first of its kind to our knowledge. A key strength of the study is the rigour of the methods. In addition, the results align with a recently published systematic review on the effects of plant-based diets on the body and the brain in the general population.[8] The authors of this review were able to demonstrate the impact of a plant based diet on metabolic measures in health and disease, but were unable to locate evidence for cognitive and mental effects. Our study differs as we were considering the research evidence for the population with mental illness, rather than the general population. Unsurprisingly, there is less evidence on the impact of a plant-based diet in this population and it is not possible to draw conclusions. Instead, this systematic review highlights this knowledge gap. It demonstrates the need for further research to explore this issue and elucidate the potentially important effects of diets on mental health. Clinically, the paucity of peer-reviewed publications on this topic indicates a concerning lack of evidence about how best to advice and guide patients with mental illness who want to optimise their diet to improve their mental and physical health. Observational research and randomised controlled trials are needed to explore the impact of plant-based diets (particularly wholefood plant-based diets) for people experiencing mental health conditions.

AUTHORSHIP

AJ, JB and UN developed the study concept. All authors contributed to the study design. Screening was performed by AJ, JB and HC. Data collection and synthesis were performed by HC. AJ, JB and HC drafted the paper. All authors approved the final version of the paper for submission.

CONFLICTS OF INTEREST

The authors declared no conflict of interest with respect to the authorship or publication of this article.

FUNDING

No funding was available for this study which was conducted by the researchers within their roles at Lancashire and South Cumbria Foundation trust.