Assessing the Impact of the Covid-19 Pandemic on US Mortality: A County-Level Analysis

Background Covid-19 excess deaths refer to increases in mortality over what would normally have been expected in the absence of the Covid-19 pandemic. Several prior studies have calculated excess deaths but were limited to the national or state level, precluding an examination of area-level variation in excess mortality and excess deaths not assigned to Covid-19. In this study, we take advantage of county-level variation in Covid-19 mortality to estimate excess deaths associated with the pandemic and examine how the extent of excess mortality not assigned to Covid-19 varies across subsets of counties defined by sociodemographic and health characteristics.

Methods and Findings We made use of National Center for Health Statistics (NCHS) data on direct Covid-19 and all-cause mortality in U.S. counties occurring from February 1 to October 17 and reported before December 15, 2020. Our sample included 787 counties with more than 20 Covid-19 deaths. We first modeled the relationship between 2020 all-cause mortality and Covid-19 mortality across all counties and then produced fully stratified models to explore differences in this relationship among strata of sociodemographic and health factors. Overall, we found that for every 100 deaths assigned to Covid-19, 144 all-cause deaths occurred (95% CI, 130 to 159), implying that 31% (95% CI, 24% to 38%) of excess deaths were ascribed to causes of death other than Covid-19 itself. Our stratified models revealed that the percentage of excess deaths not assigned to Covid-19 was substantially higher among counties in rural areas, counties with lower median household incomes and less formal education, counties with more diabetes, obesity, and smoking, and counties in the South. Counties with more non-Hispanic Black residents, who are already at high risk of Covid-19 death based on direct counts, also reported more excess deaths not assigned to Covid-19.

Conclusions Direct Covid-19 death counts in 2020 substantially underestimated total excess mortality attributable to Covid-19. Socioeconomic and racial inequities in Covid-19 mortality also increased when excess deaths not assigned to Covid-19 were considered. Our results highlight the significant role of social determinants of health in Covid-19 mortality and the importance of considering health equity in the policy response to the pandemic.