Skip to main content
medRxiv
  • Home
  • About
  • Submit
  • ALERTS / RSS
Advanced Search

The unintended consequences of inconsistent pandemic control policies

View ORCID ProfileBenjamin M. Althouse, Brendan Wallace, Brendan Case, Samuel V. Scarpino, View ORCID ProfileAntoine Allard, Andrew M. Berdahl, View ORCID ProfileEaston R. White, Laurent Hébert-Dufresne
doi: https://doi.org/10.1101/2020.08.21.20179473
Benjamin M. Althouse
1Institute for Disease Modeling, Global Health, Bill & Melinda Gates Foundation, Seattle, WA
2University of Washington, Seattle, WA 98105
3New Mexico State University, Las Cruces, NM 88003
  • Find this author on Google Scholar
  • Find this author on PubMed
  • Search for this author on this site
  • ORCID record for Benjamin M. Althouse
  • For correspondence: balthouse@idmod.org
Brendan Wallace
4Department of Applied Mathematics, University of Washington, Seattle, WA 98195, USA
  • Find this author on Google Scholar
  • Find this author on PubMed
  • Search for this author on this site
Brendan Case
5Department of Computer Science, University of Vermont, Burlington, VT 05405, USA
6Vermont Complex Systems Center, University of Vermont, Burlington, VT 05405, USA
  • Find this author on Google Scholar
  • Find this author on PubMed
  • Search for this author on this site
Samuel V. Scarpino
7Network Science Institute, Northeastern University, Boston, MA, USA
8Roux Institute, Northeastern University, Portland, ME, USA
9Santa Fe Institute, Santa Fe, NM, USA
  • Find this author on Google Scholar
  • Find this author on PubMed
  • Search for this author on this site
Antoine Allard
10Département de physique, de génie physique et d’optique, Université Laval, Québec (Québec), Canada G1V 0A6
11Centre interdisciplinaire en modélisation mathématique, Université Laval, Québec (Québec), Canada G1V 0A6
  • Find this author on Google Scholar
  • Find this author on PubMed
  • Search for this author on this site
  • ORCID record for Antoine Allard
Andrew M. Berdahl
12School of Aquatic & Fishery Sciences, University of Washington, Seattle, WA 98195, USA
  • Find this author on Google Scholar
  • Find this author on PubMed
  • Search for this author on this site
Easton R. White
13Department of Biology, University of Vermont, Burlington, VT 05405, USA
14Gund Institute for Environment, University of Vermont, Burlington, VT 05405, USA
  • Find this author on Google Scholar
  • Find this author on PubMed
  • Search for this author on this site
  • ORCID record for Easton R. White
Laurent Hébert-Dufresne
5Department of Computer Science, University of Vermont, Burlington, VT 05405, USA
6Vermont Complex Systems Center, University of Vermont, Burlington, VT 05405, USA
10Département de physique, de génie physique et d’optique, Université Laval, Québec (Québec), Canada G1V 0A6
  • Find this author on Google Scholar
  • Find this author on PubMed
  • Search for this author on this site
  • Abstract
  • Full Text
  • Info/History
  • Metrics
  • Supplementary material
  • Data/Code
  • Preview PDF
Loading

ABSTRACT

Controlling the spread of COVID-19 – even after a licensed vaccine is available – requires the effective use of non-pharmaceutical interventions, e.g., physical distancing, limits on group sizes, mask wearing, etc1–7. To date, such interventions have not been uniformly and/or systematically implemented across the United States of America (US)8. For example, even when under strict stay-at-home orders, numerous jurisdictions in the US granted exceptions and/or were in close proximity to locations with entirely different regulations in place. Here, we investigate the impact of such geographic inconsistencies in epidemic control policies by coupling high-resolution mobility, search, and COVID case data to a mathematical model of SARS-CoV-2 transmission. Our results show that while stay-at-home orders decrease contacts in most areas of the US, some specific activities and venues often see an increase in attendance. As an example, over the month of March 2020, between 10 and 30% of churches in the US saw increases in attendance; even as the total number of visits to churches declined nationally. This heterogeneity, where certain venues see substantial increases in attendance while others close, suggests that closure can cause individuals to find an open venue, even if that requires longer-distance travel. And, indeed, the average distance travelled to churches in the US rose by 13% over the same period, and over the summer, churches with more than 50 average weekly visitors saw an increase of 81% in distance visitors had to travel to attend. Strikingly, our mathematical model reveals that, across a broad range of model parameters, partial measures can often be worse than no measures at all. In the most severe cases, individuals not complying with policies by traveling to neighboring jurisdictions can create epidemics when the outbreak would otherwise have been contained. Indeed, using county-level COVID-19 data, we show that mobility from high-incidence to low-incidence associated with travel for venues like churches, parks, and gyms consistently precedes rising case numbers in the low-incidence counties. Taken together, our data analysis of nearly 120 million church visitors across 184,677 churches, 14 million grocery visitors across 7,662 grocery stores, 13.5 million gym visitors across 5,483 gyms, 7.7 million cases across 3,195 counties, and modeling results highlight the potential unintended consequences of inconsistent epidemic control policies and stress the importance of balancing the societal needs of a population with the risk of an outbreak growing into a large epidemic, and the urgent need for centralized implementation and enforcement of non-pharmaceutical interventions.

Competing Interest Statement

The authors have declared no competing interest.

Funding Statement

B.C. is supported as a Fellow of the National Science Foundation under NRT award DGE-1735316. S.V.S. is supported by startup funds provided by Northeastern University. E.R.W. was supported by the COVID-19 Rapid Research Fund from the Gund Institute for Environment at the University of Vermont. L.H.-D. acknowledges support from the National Institutes of Health 1P20 GM125498-01 Centers of Biomedical Research Excellence Award. The funders had no role in study design, data collection, data analysis, the decision to publish, or preparation of the manuscript.

Author Declarations

I confirm all relevant ethical guidelines have been followed, and any necessary IRB and/or ethics committee approvals have been obtained.

Yes

The details of the IRB/oversight body that provided approval or exemption for the research described are given below:

N/A

All necessary patient/participant consent has been obtained and the appropriate institutional forms have been archived.

Yes

I understand that all clinical trials and any other prospective interventional studies must be registered with an ICMJE-approved registry, such as ClinicalTrials.gov. I confirm that any such study reported in the manuscript has been registered and the trial registration ID is provided (note: if posting a prospective study registered retrospectively, please provide a statement in the trial ID field explaining why the study was not registered in advance).

Yes

I have followed all appropriate research reporting guidelines and uploaded the relevant EQUATOR Network research reporting checklist(s) and other pertinent material as supplementary files, if applicable.

Yes

Footnotes

  • Revised manuscript to incorporate analyses beyond March 2020 and include incidence data in new analyses. Revised supplementary materials.

Data Availability

All data are freely available. SafeGraph data can be obtained here: https://www.safegraph.com/covid-19-data-consortium. Google API for search can be applied for here: https://docs.google.com/forms/d/e/1FAIpQLSenHdGiGl1YF-7rVDDmmulN8R-ra9MnGLLs7gIIaAX9VHPdPg/viewform. COVID case data by county can be obtained here: https://github.com/CSSEGISandData/COVID-19/tree/master/csse_covid_19_data Model was written in C++ and is available here: https://github.com/LaurentHebert/cloSIR

Copyright 
The copyright holder for this preprint is the author/funder, who has granted medRxiv a license to display the preprint in perpetuity. It is made available under a CC-BY-NC 4.0 International license.
Back to top
PreviousNext
Posted October 28, 2020.
Download PDF

Supplementary Material

Data/Code
Email

Thank you for your interest in spreading the word about medRxiv.

NOTE: Your email address is requested solely to identify you as the sender of this article.

Enter multiple addresses on separate lines or separate them with commas.
The unintended consequences of inconsistent pandemic control policies
(Your Name) has forwarded a page to you from medRxiv
(Your Name) thought you would like to see this page from the medRxiv website.
CAPTCHA
This question is for testing whether or not you are a human visitor and to prevent automated spam submissions.
Share
The unintended consequences of inconsistent pandemic control policies
Benjamin M. Althouse, Brendan Wallace, Brendan Case, Samuel V. Scarpino, Antoine Allard, Andrew M. Berdahl, Easton R. White, Laurent Hébert-Dufresne
medRxiv 2020.08.21.20179473; doi: https://doi.org/10.1101/2020.08.21.20179473
Digg logo Reddit logo Twitter logo Facebook logo Google logo LinkedIn logo Mendeley logo
Citation Tools
The unintended consequences of inconsistent pandemic control policies
Benjamin M. Althouse, Brendan Wallace, Brendan Case, Samuel V. Scarpino, Antoine Allard, Andrew M. Berdahl, Easton R. White, Laurent Hébert-Dufresne
medRxiv 2020.08.21.20179473; doi: https://doi.org/10.1101/2020.08.21.20179473

Citation Manager Formats

  • BibTeX
  • Bookends
  • EasyBib
  • EndNote (tagged)
  • EndNote 8 (xml)
  • Medlars
  • Mendeley
  • Papers
  • RefWorks Tagged
  • Ref Manager
  • RIS
  • Zotero
  • Tweet Widget
  • Facebook Like
  • Google Plus One

Subject Area

  • Public and Global Health
Subject Areas
All Articles
  • Addiction Medicine (164)
  • Allergy and Immunology (417)
  • Anesthesia (93)
  • Cardiovascular Medicine (867)
  • Dentistry and Oral Medicine (159)
  • Dermatology (98)
  • Emergency Medicine (251)
  • Endocrinology (including Diabetes Mellitus and Metabolic Disease) (398)
  • Epidemiology (8597)
  • Forensic Medicine (4)
  • Gastroenterology (391)
  • Genetic and Genomic Medicine (1775)
  • Geriatric Medicine (170)
  • Health Economics (376)
  • Health Informatics (1252)
  • Health Policy (625)
  • Health Systems and Quality Improvement (472)
  • Hematology (198)
  • HIV/AIDS (380)
  • Infectious Diseases (except HIV/AIDS) (10354)
  • Intensive Care and Critical Care Medicine (554)
  • Medical Education (193)
  • Medical Ethics (51)
  • Nephrology (214)
  • Neurology (1692)
  • Nursing (97)
  • Nutrition (252)
  • Obstetrics and Gynecology (330)
  • Occupational and Environmental Health (451)
  • Oncology (934)
  • Ophthalmology (265)
  • Orthopedics (104)
  • Otolaryngology (172)
  • Pain Medicine (115)
  • Palliative Medicine (40)
  • Pathology (256)
  • Pediatrics (541)
  • Pharmacology and Therapeutics (257)
  • Primary Care Research (210)
  • Psychiatry and Clinical Psychology (1788)
  • Public and Global Health (3877)
  • Radiology and Imaging (629)
  • Rehabilitation Medicine and Physical Therapy (324)
  • Respiratory Medicine (525)
  • Rheumatology (208)
  • Sexual and Reproductive Health (171)
  • Sports Medicine (159)
  • Surgery (191)
  • Toxicology (36)
  • Transplantation (101)
  • Urology (76)