Abstract
We report the single-strand Recombinase Polymerase Amplification (ssRPA) method, which merges the fast, isothermal amplification of RPA with subsequent rapid conversion of the double-strand DNA amplicon to single strands, and hence enables facile hybridization-based, high-specificity readout. We demonstrate the utility of ssRPA for sensitive and rapid (4 copies per 50 µL reaction within 10 min, or 8 copies within 8 min) visual detection of SARS-CoV-2 RNA spiked samples, as well as clinical saliva and nasopharyngeal swabs in VTM or water, on lateral flow devices. The ssRPA method promises rapid, sensitive, and accessible RNA detection to facilitate mass testing in the COVID-19 pandemic.
Introduction
Effective and accessible mass testing can help to limit the spread of the current SARS-CoV-2 pandemic. While serology testing reveals recent and past exposure, RNA testing allows early detection of active infection. Standard RT-qPCR1 and relatives2–10 achieve high analytical sensitivity (1–100 copies of viral RNA per input μ1)11, but take hours and require relatively complex equipment. New sequencing approaches promise high multiplexing but slow response further12–15. In contrast, isothermal methods such as Recombinase Polymerase Amplification (RPA)16–22, Recombinase-Aided Amplification (RAA)23, Nicking Enzyme Amplification Reaction (NEAR)24, Loop-mediated isothermal Amplification (LAMP)25–39, and Rapid Amplification (RAMP, an RPA + LAMP combination)25 typically detect 10–1000 copies of RNA per reaction with minimal or no instrumentation (see review40). The RPA reaction can generate double-stranded DNA (dsDNA) amplicons particularly quickly, but its recombinase-driven priming process is prone to multi-base mismatching that necessitates an additional specificity check39,41. Augmentation of RPA with conditionally extensible primers or cleavable inter-primer probes enhances specificity16,42,43, but tends to reduce reaction speed. Alternatively, Cas1234 or Cas1319,44 nucleases applied to amplification products generate signal in a sequence specific manner, but incur substantial increases in workflow complexity and reaction time. Here, we describe “single-strand RPA” (ssRPA) method, which applies (1) rapid amplification of dsDNA, (2) conversion to ssDNA, and (3) sequence-specific, hybridization-based readout, arranged to maintain both optimal speed and accuracy (Fig. 1a). For amplification, we apply basic RT-RPA16 in the absence of any specificity-enhancing components that may inhibit speed. For ssDNA conversion, we use an exonuclease to digest strands except those chemically protected. Finally, hybridization-based readout is shown with LFDs.
Results
We selected the 5′ end of the SARS-CoV-2 spike protein sequence as our main detection target. Per the detailed protocol of Fig. 1b (and Supplementary Protocol), we diluted the sample in a basic RT-RPA reaction mixture, modifying the forward primer with a 5′ tail of 6 phosphorothioate-linked bases to confer exonuclease protection45,46. The reaction was run for 5 min at 42°C on a heating block. A sample of the product was then treated with sodium dodecyl sulfate (SDS) and diluted into an exonuclease and lateral flow (exo/LFD) buffer, where the unprotected strand in the dsDNA was rapidly (≤ 1 min) digested by a T7 exonuclease to yield the protected ssDNA target45,46. A pair of 3′-biotin and 5′-FAM modified probes in the digestion buffer were available to target sequences in between the amplification priming domains, providing specificity not achievable with RPA priming alone. The correct target ssDNA therefore acted as a bridge that co-localized both detection probes within an LFD, ultimately binding gold nanoparticles to the biotin-ligand test line to produce visual readout as early as 1–2 minutes. Full amplification and detection timelines are described in Fig. 1c.
We first tested ssRPA on buffer-spiked samples. Figure 1d (and Supplementary Fig. S1) shows LFD detection of synthetic SARS-CoV-2 full genome standard serially diluted in DNase/RNase-free water, photographed at multiple intervals on the same strips. Concentrations of input RNA were quantified by RT-qPCR and direct comparison to spectrophotometricallyquantified synthetic standards (Fig. S2). Results show detection of 8 copies per 50 µL reaction by naked eye within 8 min (2 min LFD), or 4 copies within 10 min (4 min LFD), and a dynamic range of at least 5 orders of magnitude No test line signal formed for the no-template negative controls over > 60 min of LFD incubation. To test for assay reliability, we spiked 5 µL human saliva with 8 copies of cultured, heat-inactivated virus and showed 20 of 20 positive tests within 8 min (Figs. 1e and S3). To test for specificity, we performed ssRPA on water spiked with viral RNA from 8 other respiratory viruses, including genomically similar coronaviruses and alternative diagnoses, each at > 105 copies per assay. None exhibited false positive signals (Figs. 1f and S4). Finally, we performed a blinded assay on clinical samples, with a technician unaware of patient type or qPCR result correctly identifying the type (positive or negative) of all 18 samples at 2 min LFD time. Nasopharyngeal (NP) swabs stored in viral transport media (VTM), NP swabs stored in water, and saliva samples were processed by single-tube RNA extraction (1:1 mixture with extraction buffer, 95 °C × 2 min)47 and used at 10% v/v in RT-RPA (Figs. 1g and S5). All clinical samples were also semi-quantified by RT-qPCR, using column extraction/concentration and CDC N2 primers (Fig. 1g, S7). Results of this limited study demonstrate 100% sensitivity and 100% specificity across all sample types, including NP swabs in water and saliva samples with lower titers (high Ct).
Discussion
The ssRPA method combines the speed of established RT-RPA16 with the sequence specificity of ssDNA hybridization by serially applying RPA and exonuclease steps. It enables best-in-class performance on the principal axes of reaction time and sensitivity, enabling the detection of 8 copies in 8 min or 4 copies in 10 min. The conceptual framework could be generalized to other isothermal readout methods with dsDNA output for achieving optimal sensitivity and speed. The present method may also be further developed to achieve single-nucleotide specificity, for example by using toehold probe readout19, and spatial multiplexing readout on LFDs with multiple test positions. We also expect future development, including simplified workflow and use of lyophilized reagents for ambient distribution and storage, will further facilitate mass testing.
Data Availability
All relevant data are included within the manuscript and supplemental information. Please contact corresponding authors for more information.
The authors have applied for patents based on the work. P.Y. is a co-founder and director of Ultivue, Inc., NuProbe Global, and Torus Biosystems, Inc.
Supplemental Information
Methods
Protocol: ssRPA-LFD.
Figure S1: Gels and full-length images of strips in main text Fig. 1d (sensitivity).
Figure S2: Quantification of spike-in RNA.
Figure S3: Full-length images of LFD strips in main text Fig. 1e (extended sensitivity).
Figure S4: Full-length images of LFD strips in main text Fig. 1f (specificity).
Figure S5: Gels and full-length images of LFD strips in main text Fig. 1g (clinical samples).
Figure S6: Demonstration of efficacy of extraction protocol.
Figure S7: Relative quantification of clinical sample RNA.
Methods
Sample sources
Synthetic SARS-CoV-2 RNA (Twist Biosciences, 102019) was used in sample qPCR quantification and in the serial dilution experiment of Fig. 1d. Synthetic fragment RNA (IDT), constituting the 76 nt region beginning at the 5′ end of the spike sequence (“5′ S region”), was used in sample qPCR quantification and ordered as Ultramers at 20 nmol scale. All synthetic primers and probes (IDT) were chemically synthesized with any specified modifications, ordered at 100 or 250 nmol scale, desalted or PAGE-purified, and used as is. Viral genomic RNA (isolated from infected cells) from coronaviruses 229E (ATCC, VR-740D), MERS (BEI, NR-50549), SARS-CoV-1 (BEI, NR-52346), and NL63 (BEI, NR-44105), as well as influenza A (ATCC, VR-1736D), influenza B (ATCC, VR-1535D), respiratory syncytial virus (ATCC, VR-1580DQ), and rhinovirus (ATCC, VR-1663D), were used for the specificity experiment in Fig. 1e. Cultured and heat-inactivated SARS-CoV-2 viral RNA (BEI, NR-52286) was used in specificity (Fig. 1e) and in spiked saliva (Fig. 1f) experiments. Pooled human saliva from ≥ 3 de-identified donors (Lee Biosolutions, 991-05-P) was collected prior to November 2019 and used to prepare the contrived samples. All clinical samples (Fig. 1g) were purchased from BioCollections Worldwide, Inc. and heat-inactivated at 95 °C for 5 min prior to shipping.
Primer and probe design
Relatively clean RPA products are the result of multiple primer pairs designed in silico for the appropriate salt and temperature conditions (NUPACK.org) and extensively tested empirically, with the goal of minimizing primer dimers and other unintended reactions that might slow the targeted amplification. RPA primer sequences and LFD probes for SARS-CoV-2 5′ spike target were as follows, where “*” denotes a phosphorothioate bond (for exonuclease protection), “/iFluorT/” denotes an internal FAM fluorophore (for nanoparticle capture), “/3ddC/” denotes 3′ dideoxycytidine (to prevent 3′ end extension), and “/3Bio/” denotes 3′ biotin (for test line capture). Here, the probe sequences partly overlap with primer sequences, but not enough to bind significantly to those sequences in isolation. This overlap is not necessary. Also note that, for extended protection, an internal fluorescein with poly-phosphorothioate protection is noted here, though we have had similar results with a simple 5′ /56-FAM/ moiety. Probes and primers for 5′ spike were: Fwd primer: T*T*T*T*T*T* TGGGTTATCTTCAACCTAGGACTTTTCTAT; Rev primer: CCAACCTGAAGAAGAATCA CCAGGAGTCAA; FAM LFD probe: T*T*T*T*T*T*T /iFluorT/ TTTTTTTTTTTTT AGGAGTCAA ATAACTT/3ddC/; Biotin LFD probe: T*T*T*T*T*T* TATGTAAA GCAAGTAAAG TTTTTTTTTTTTTTT /3Bio/.
Sample preparation
SARS-CoV-2 samples were quantified in-house, comparing fluorometrically-quantified synthetic RNA fragments (IDT), Twist Biosciences qPCR RNA standards, and culture-derived BEI viral genome samples, all diluted in DNase/RNase-free water (See SI Fig.S2). Synthetic fragment (IDT) RNA segment was quantified by Nanodrop spectrophotometry by blanking with IDTE buffer (IDT) and then measuring absorbance at 260 nm with a 2 µl sample volume. Ten-fold serial dilutions of the synthetic fragment (IDT) RNA segment were made from 107 copies/µl down to 103 copies/µl in DNase/RNase-free water, using low binding tips and tubes to avoid sample loss. Similarly, Twist synthetic SARS-CoV-2 RNA were serially diluted in ten-fold (0.1×, 0.01×, 0.001×) for comparison. Amplification by qPCR (Bio-Rad, CFX Connect) was then performed with 4× TaqPath 1-Step RT-qPCR master mix (Life Science, A15300), 5′ spike primers (100 nM), and EvaGreen dye (Thermofisher) at 20 µl total volume with 1 µl sample volume. A linear regression was performed on the Ct and expected dilution concentrations of the standard (R2 = 0.99745), and in turn used to convert sample Ct to absolute quantities of 552000, 55400, and 7200 copies/µl, respectively. This quantified Twist sample was then used in a dilution series to quantify the culture-derived (BEI) RNA using Charite “E” primer and sequence-specific probe set (IDT). Here, qPCR was performed with 5 µl of 4× TaqPath 1-Step RT-qPCR master mix, 3 µl of Charite “E” primers/probes, and 7 µl of DNase/RNase-free water at 20 µl total volume with 5 µl input sample volume. Simple and contrived samples were prepared by further diluting quantified samples as necessary, spiking into DNase/RNase-free water or pooled human saliva at ∼ 2 or more copies per 5 µl, and used directly in RT-RPA reactions. For the specificity experiments, genomic RNA from 8 respiratory viruses were spiked in DNase/RNase-free water at 105 copies/µl, unless noted (in which case quantification was not supplied from source). As a positive control, heat inactivated SARS-CoV-2 virus was used at 100 copies/µl. All were diluted 1:50 (1 µl input into 50 µl total reaction volume) in the RT-RPA reaction mixture.
RT-RPA
A mixture of 2.5 µl each of 10 µM forward and reverse primers to the specified target, 29.5 µl of TwistAmp Basic RPA rehydration buffer (TwistDx, TABAS03KIT), 5 µl of DNase/RNase-free water, and 0.5 µl of Protoscript II reverse transcriptase (NEB, M0368S) were vortexed briefly and added to the TwistAmp lyophilized powder mix. Then, 5 µl of sample was added to the tube while 5 µl of 280 mM Magnesium Acetate was added to the reaction tube lid. The 50 µl mixture was vortexed briefly, spun down, vortexed again, spun down once more and immediately incubated at 42 °C for 5 min in a standard PCR machine (Applied Biosystems, 4484073) or heating block (Benchmark Scientific, BSH300).
Amplicon digestion
During amplification, a digestion and LFD buffer mixture was prepared with 64 µl of LFD running buffer (Milenia, MGHD 1), 1 µl of 10 µM biotin probes, 1 µl of 10 µM FAM probes, 10 µl of 10× NEBuffer 4 (NEB, B7004S), and 4 µl of T7 exonuclease (NEB, M0263S), in a total volume of 80 µl. The mixture was vortexed briefly and added to a 2 mL lo-bind tube (Eppendorf). Once complete, 8 µl of the RT-RPA reaction was subsequently mixed thoroughly and completely with a 10% Sodium Dodecyl Sulfate (SDS) at a ratio of 8 µl sample:12 µl SDS to inactivate enzymes. This 20 µl mixture was then added to the 80 µl digestion mixture above and incubated for 1 min at room temperature.
Electrophoresis
All gels (8 × 8 cm) were denaturing PAGE at 15% polyacrylamide (Invitrogen, EC6885BOX), run in 1× TBE buffer that was diluted from 10× TBE (Promega, V4251) with filtered water, at 65 °C, 200V, for 30 min. Immediately after 5 min of RT-RPA, 5 µl of products were directly mixed with 5 µl of formamide dye consisted of 100% formamide (Thermofisher) and Bromophenol blue dye (Sigma Aldrich). Gels were then removed from cassettes, stained in 1× SybrGold (Life Technologies) for 3 min, and imaged with a Typhoon scanner (General Electric). Ladders shown are 25–766 nt DNA (NEB, #B7025).
Lateral flow assay
A standard HybriDetect LFD strip (Milenia Biotec, MGHD 1) was inserted into the 2 mL Eppendorf tube above, arrows pointing up/away from the mixture, with care taken not to handle the strip roughly. Note that strips are covered with a membrane that protects the nitrocellulose and supported by a semi-rigid backing card. The strip was incubated for 2 min or longer, as desired.
Materials needed
- TwistAmp Basic Kit (thawed at ambient temperature); this protocol is specifically written to use these dried powder kits (Basic Kit) and has yet to be verified for the TwistAmp Liquid Kit
- Forward primer 10 µM (IDT)
- Reverse primer 10 µM (IDT)
- RNA template
- Protoscript II reverse transcriptase (NEB, M0368S)
- DNase/RNase-free water
- SDS
- Lateral flow strips and buffer (Milenia, MGHD 1)
Quick RNA extraction protocol (adapted from Ladha et al, doi:10.1101/2020.05.07.20055947)
0.1. Take 5 µl of patient sample (whether VTM, water, or saliva)
0.2. Mix with 5 µl of Lucigen DNA extraction buffer
0.3. Incubate at 95 °C for 2 minutes
0.4. Take out the tube and immediately keep on ice
0.5. Use 5 µl (out of the total 10 µl per sample) for ssRPA
ssRPA protocol
Step 1: Set up and run RPA (on PRE-AMPLIFICATION BENCH)
* Please have the heat block set up before setting up reaction to ensure reaction time.
1.1. Prepare (per reaction) in the following order at room temperature: Vortex ∼ 3 seconds and spin briefly (∼ 3 seconds).
If making a master mix, ensure that ∼(n+1)× master mix solution is mixed for n samples to ensure that all samples get the full, correct amount of master mix.
1.2. Add above reaction to a TwistAmp Basic reaction (dried powder included in TwistDX kit). Do not mix or pipette up and down. Then add 5 µL of RNA template directly into the tube (or water for the negative control).
1.3. Add 5 µL of 280 mM Magnesium Acetate (included in TwistDX kit) to tube lid (this way, MgOAc is kept separate in the tube lid prior to overall mixing). Carefully close tube lid without touching the inside of the tube lid (to avoid any contamination from previous amplicons or other sources), vortex briefly (∼ 2 seconds), spin down briefly (∼ 2 seconds on a micro-centrifuge), then vortex again ∼ 2 seconds to start reaction. Spin briefly (∼ 2 seconds) before the next step.
1.4. Immediately, incubate it at 42 °C for 5 minutes.*
Step 2: Set up LFD (on POST-AMPLIFICATION bench)
2.1. While RPA is running, prepare (per reaction) the following in a 2 mL lo-bind tube: Vortex and spin briefly, then to each add: Vortex and spin briefly.
2.2. Add 12 µL of 10% SDS to lid of the tube. (Avoid long spin-down of 10% SDS solution, and make sure to store at room temperature prior to this addition.) Once RPA reaction is complete, immediately vortex RPA samples for 3-5 seconds. Then add 8 µL of RPA sample to lid and pipette up and down 25-30 times quickly and vigorously until white bubbles appear to mix RPA sample with SDS. Immediately, spin solution down, vortex for 5 seconds, spin for 5 seconds.
2.3. Incubate at room temperature for 1 minute (for exonuclease digestion).
2.4. Place the lateral flow strip into tube, incubate for 2 minutes (but may wait up to an hour).
Acknowledgements
We acknowledge support from NIH 1DP1GM133052-01 and the Wyss Institute Molecular Robotics Initiative. We thank Girija Goyal and Don Ingber for inactivated SARS-CoV-2 samples, and Robert Rasmussen for help with safety and regulatory compliance. Noted reagents were obtained through BEI Resources, NIAID, NIH.