Is my Arm moving? Proprioceptive impairment in Developmental Dyslexia

Abstract

Developmental Dyslexia is a specific learning disorder causing reading deficits. Although it has long been considered a purely cognitive disorder, mounting evidence revealed that Developmental Dyslexia is associated with sensory impairments. Because these impairments are restrained to vision and hearing – both senses being heavily involved in reading – a large controversy exists regarding their role in the pathophysiology of Developmental Dyslexia. Cognitive theories argue that sensory impairments are caused by the lack of reading practice, and mainly represent an aggravating factor. Sensory theories argue that damaged neural mechanisms cause sensory impairments that, themselves, cause reading disabilities. An important prediction from sensory theories is that sensory troubles should encompass the whole sensory system. Here, we directly tested proprioceptive acuity in dyslexic children and age-matched controls. We used a well-known speed perception task where a robotic manipulandum passively rotates a child’s elbow and the child presses a trigger as soon as he felts the motion. Although dyslexics and controls equally well detected salient stimuli, dyslexics were strongly impaired at detecting weaker stimuli. Furthermore, we found that proprioceptive acuity positively correlated with reading abilities. These results cannot be explained by a lack of reading practice and thus strongly support sensory theories of Developmental Dyslexia.