The impact of early social distancing at COVID-19 Outbreak in the largest Metropolitan Area of Brazil

The study

We evaluated the impact of early social distancing measures in the transmission of COVID-19 in the SPMA, and projected the number of ICU beds necessary for COVID-19 patients in Brazil.

During the epidemic, the Brazilian Ministry of Health (MoH) implemented an electronic form for reporting suspected cases of respiratory syndrome. We retrieved all confirmed COVID-19 cases between 26^th February and 30^th March. The form includes several different information, such as exposure and travel information, the contact names of people that could be infected (primary cases), the date of onset of symptoms, and laboratory results. Using only locally acquired cases, we linked the reported contacts with the original dataset of confirmed cases in order to create a set of infection pairs. We then compared the dates of onset of symptoms to establish the set of serial intervals. In addition, we used the daily number of COVID-19 confirmed patients from a São Paulo state to calculate time dependent reproductive number R(t).

In 2009, the MoH established a mandatory notification of any hospitalized case of severe acute respiratory illness (SARI) into the National Disease Notification System (SIVEP-GRIPE). We retrieved all SARI cases notified on the SIVEP-GRIPE system between 26^th February and 30^th March (5). Those cases were included regardless of COVID19 confirmation as a proxy of COVID19 infections. This proxy was used to validate R(t) of confirmed COVID19 cases and was chosen in order to minimize the impact on shortage of RT-PCR tests.

We calculated the R(t) during one month period for confirmed cases of COVID19, as well as SARI in the SPMA, and estimated the expected number of COVID19 cases requiring an ICU bed. The reproductive number at the beginning of the epidemic (R0) and during the epidemic (Rt) were calculated using the package R0 R Studio (3). The expected ICU demand was calculated using an age stratified SEIR model (7), which includes compartments for individuals requiring hospitalization and intensive care. The parameters are described in Table 1.

Considering only the confirmed cases reported by São Paulo State, the R0 (i.e. previously to the introduction of social distancing measures) was close to 2. During the interventions, the R(t) dropped to values close to 1 and had a subsequent increase (Figure 1a). Underreporting and the shortage of confirmatory tests for COVID19 could directly affect these R(t) estimations. To deal with this, we analyzed the number of SARI available in the Epidemiological Surveillance of Influenza System (SIVEP-GRIPE) and showed that the social distancing measures reduced the R(t) below to 1 with a more accurate confidence interval (Figure 1b). The R(t) of SARI cases was used in the SEIR model to forecasted the ICU beds necessary and the number of deaths.

• Download figure
• Open in new tab

Figure 1.

Time-dependent reproductive number R(t) estimated for the confirmed COVID19 cases (a), and for the SARI cases (b). Solid line corresponds to R(t), red area to the confidence interval, vertical dotted line represents, respectively the date of the onset of symptoms of the first confirmed case in Brazil and date of the first social distancing measure implemented by the São Paulo state.

In the absence of social distancing measures, the model predicts that in the end of 30 days, COVID19 patients would demand 5,384 ICU beds, which corresponds to 230% of the ICU capacity and exceed 14 times the ICU capacity in the second month. Overall, this would result in 1,783 deaths in the first month and 89,349 in the second month. With maintenance of social distancing measures, the model predicts 317 deaths in the first month and a total of 1682 in the second. This scenario does not overburden the healthcare system and requires a maximum of 76% ICU beds capacity.

The impact of the social distancing measures must be monitored daily based on the number of hospitalized SARI, especially during the shortage of the COVID-19 confirmation tests. Using the severe cases notification systems, we identified that the social distance measures implemented in the SPMA reduced the COVID19 R(t) to below 1. In April and May, during influenza seasonality, with the maintenance of this level of social distance, the SPMA will need no additional ICU beds for COVID19 patients.

We realized that the downward trend seems to have started before the intervention. This could be explained by a decrease in mobility documented since the first days of March in places like national parks, public beaches, marinas, dog parks, plazas, and public gardens. According to a COVID-19 Community Mobility Report performed by Google this reduction was intensified and spread to other settings since the local government declared a state of emergency (9). This report suggested that intervention was effectively applied, and it is consistent with the transmissibility reduction observed.

The baseline scenario shows that completely relaxing social distancing produces thousands of additional deaths. Figure 2 shows that the rate of fatalities per day increases dramatically when ICU capacity is overloaded. The simulation shows that the number of deaths per day in this scenario quickly spikes from 100, a week prior the system is overloaded, to a peak of 4,160 deaths per day in less than a month.

• Download figure
• Open in new tab

Figure 2.

Estimation of the number of ICU patients (Black line) and fatalities (Red line). The solid line uses the time dependent reproductive number R(t) measured for SPMA and the dashed line represents the scenario in which no social distancing takes place. The vertical dashed line represents the date in which the local government declared a state of emergency and the horizontal gray line represents the number of available ICU beds.

Several factors may impact our predictions. To minimize the impact on our estimations caused by the delay between the patient’s onset of symptoms are reported we censored the last week of data. Another potential limitation is that outbreaks of COVID19 in nearby cities could lead to an overburden in the SPMA healthcare system, which is a reference for the State of São Paulo, even if the epidemic is controlled in the SPMA.

Conclusions

Despite the limitations, we reported through SARI electronic notification systems as a proxy for severe cases of COVID19 an important decrease on the R(t) after two week of the implementation of social distance measures in the SPMA. These measures are expected to avoid 89,450 deaths in 60 days even without any increase in total ICU bed capacity.

Fabiana S.G. dos Santos is a biologist and PhD candidate. Her main research interest is epidemiology of infectious diseases and mathematical modelling